Live tracker: Draft Conversion Practices Bill (England and Wales)

This tracker follows the Draft Conversion Practices Bill through pre-legislative scrutiny. It brings together the official parliamentary record, the principal unresolved questions, Protect and Teach’s published work, and selected substantive stakeholder evidence.

Last updated: 20 November 2026

Live tracker: This page will be updated as the Joint Committee publishes evidence, holds meetings and hearings, reports to Parliament, and as the Government responds or brings forward further legislation.

Key dates and what happens next

25 June 2026Government published the draft Conversion Practices Bill for England and Wales.
20 October 2026Joint Committee inquiry opened.
29 OctoberOral evidence: Stonewall, Galop, Ban Conversion Practices Coalition; Gay Men’s Network, Sex Matters, LGB Alliance.
2 NovemberOral evidence: Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith.
12 NovemberOral evidence: Moon, Berner, Morrison and Hutchinson. Two uncorrected transcripts subsequently published.
16 NovemberWritten evidence closed at 5 pm. Cass, Leng and healthcare regulators gave oral evidence.
19 NovemberFifth oral-evidence hearing completed: Des Johnson (FFLAG), Shabana Jaffar (Cafcass), Matilda Gosling and Sarah Branson (Family Law Bar Association). Official transcript (Q188–248).
20 NovemberProtect and Teach CIC published its comparison of five hearings with its September 769-page evidence review.
23 NovemberFurther oral evidence listed, 4:20 pm public session.
26 NovemberFurther oral evidence listed, 11:20 am public session.
22 January 2027Joint Committee report due. This is not the date the Bill becomes law.
After the reportGovernment may respond and introduce legislation when parliamentary time allows. No introduction, Royal Assent or commencement date has been set.

Hearing dates can change. Check Parliament’s live inquiry diary.

Latest verified position — 20 November 2026

Official parliamentary record The Joint Committee has now held five oral-evidence hearings: 29 October, 2 November, 12 November, 16 November and 19 November. The written-evidence deadline closed at 5 pm on 16 November. Further sessions are listed for 23 and 26 November; check the official diary for changes.

19 November — family law and children: The Committee heard Des Johnson (FFLAG), Shabana Jaffar (Cafcass), Matilda Gosling and Sarah Branson (Family Law Bar Association). Questions addressed existing family-law powers and significant harm (Q189, Q205–206), the meaning of abuse and lawful parenting (Q203–225), proposed protection orders (Q238–245) and children of criminal-responsibility age (Q247–248). Read the official transcript. Witness views are not Committee findings.

16 November — Cass and regulators: Baroness Hilary Cass told the Committee she did not support the Bill as drafted (Q149), while distinguishing that position from support for protecting people against abusive practices. Professor Gillian Leng and professional regulators discussed clinical exploration, existing standards and regulatory mechanisms. Read the official transcript.

New Protect and Teach analysis — 20 November The Conversion Practices Bill: Five Parliamentary Hearings, but Where Is the Evidence That New Criminal Law Is Needed? compares testimony with the September 769-page review, including prevalence, claimed gaps in existing law, causation, clinical safeguards, parental responsibility and protection orders. Its conclusions are Protect and Teach CIC’s assessment, not findings adopted by the Committee.

Legal status: The Bill remains a draft undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny. No new criminal offence or protection order has been enacted by this draft.

20 November — What did five parliamentary hearings establish?

Protect and Teach CIC evidence assessment Our new analysis tests the five hearings against the principal questions in our September evidence review, particularly Appendix B (claimed gaps in existing law) and Appendix C (prevalence, methodology and impact assumptions).

  • Legislative necessity: limitations in individual legal mechanisms were discussed, but a material category of serious abusive conduct requiring this new offence was not demonstrated.
  • Prevalence and causation: testimony and additional polling did not establish the frequency of conduct meeting every element of the proposed offence or validate the Government’s causal and preventive-effect assumptions.
  • Clinical practice: the witnesses differed on whether the proposed wording adequately protects legitimate exploration and professional judgement; Baroness Cass opposed the draft as written.
  • Parents and children: the 19 November family-law evidence raised concerns about statutory clarity, ordinary parenting decisions, protection orders and children aged 10 or above.
  • Preventive orders: witnesses identified possible benefits and practical uncertainties; the need for this particular CPPO framework was not established.

Important distinction: these are our conclusions about the evidence required to justify the proposed law. They do not deny reported abuse, establish that every harmful act is already criminal, or amount to a Committee recommendation.

Read the full five-hearing analysis, comparison table and sources · Read the September 2026 evidence review (PDF).

Parliamentary evidence library — recordings, transcripts and selected clips

Start with the complete official recording or transcript. Shorter X clips are supplementary excerpts and may omit context. Uncorrected transcripts record witness evidence, not agreed Committee conclusions.

29 October — stakeholder panels

Witnesses: Stephen Kiely, Kai O’Doherty, Professor Ilias Trispiotis; Dennis Kavanagh, Helen Joyce and Dermot Kehoe.

Official hearing and recording · Panel 1 transcript · Panel 2 transcript

Selected clips: Helen Joyce extract shared by Venice Allan · Additional hearing extract. See the historical hearing section for contextual notes.

2 November — Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith
12 November — clinicians and professional bodies

Witnesses: Dr Igi Moon, Dr Alison Berner; Dr Lisa Morrison (BACP), Dr Anna Hutchinson.

Official recording · Official transcript (Q80–126).

Stakeholder clips: Sex Matters and Transgender Trend circulated extracts concerning professional regulation, complaints and exploratory practice. Individual original post URLs have not been supplied; no links or verbatim quotations are invented.

16 November — Cass, Leng and healthcare regulators

4:20 pm: Baroness Hilary Cass and Professor Gillian Leng. 5:10 pm: Dr Arun Chopra (CQC), Andrew Smith (HCPC), Mark Swindells (GMC).

Official hearing and full recording · Official transcript (Q127–187).

Cass stated that she did not support the Bill as drafted (Q149). See the complete transcript for the surrounding discussion of clinical care and professional regulation; stakeholder clips are supplementary.

19 November — family-law witnesses, parents and protection orders

Witnesses: Des Johnson (FFLAG), Shabana Jaffar (Cafcass), Matilda Gosling and Sarah Branson (Family Law Bar Association).

Official transcript (Q188–248) · Official inquiry page.

Key exchanges: significant harm and existing family-law jurisdiction (Q189, Q205–206); ordinary parenting and legal certainty (Q203–225); protection orders (Q238–245); children and criminal liability (Q247–248). Read the complete transcript rather than relying solely on clips.

Next listed hearings: 23 and 26 November — latest official diary.

What happens after the Committee reports?

The Committee is due to report by 22 January 2027. The Government can consider its recommendations, respond and decide whether to introduce a Bill. Any introduced Bill would then need to pass the usual parliamentary stages in both Houses and receive Royal Assent. Commencement may be later. No date has been announced for introduction, enactment or commencement.

↑ Back to contents

Archive — verified position at 14 November 2026 (superseded above)

Parliamentary record The Joint Committee has held oral-evidence sessions on 29 October, 2 November and 12 November 2026. The official 12 November programme identifies Dr Igi Moon and Dr Alison Berner at 11:15 am, followed by Dr Lisa Morrison (BACP) and Dr Anna Hutchinson at 12:10 pm. The official event page and recording are the primary source for the hearing. Earlier entries below describing this hearing as forthcoming or its witnesses as unconfirmed are historical snapshots and have been superseded.

Upcoming Further public oral-evidence sessions are listed for Monday 16 November at 4:20 pm and Thursday 19 November at 11:20 am. The written-evidence deadline remains Monday 16 November at 5 pm (UK time). Official inquiry diary and call for evidence.

Legal status: This is a draft Bill undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny, not enacted law. Witness statements, ministerial assurances, media reports and stakeholder interpretations do not amend its provisions.

12 November 2026 — Joint Committee hears clinicians and professional bodies (earlier evidence note)

Hearing completed The Committee heard Dr Igi Moon (Memorandum of Understanding on Conversion Therapies), Dr Alison Berner (British Association of Gender Identity Specialists), Dr Lisa Morrison (British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy) and Dr Anna Hutchinson (Integrated Psychology Clinic). Official hearing and recording.

Questions highlighted for detailed scrutiny: the relationship between sexual orientation and transgender identity; whether existing criminal law and professional regulation already address the conduct targeted; the position of children compared with adults; and whether the draft’s terms could affect access to exploratory clinical care. Accounts circulated by Sex Matters and Transgender Trend report exchanges involving Lord Hope and the Chair. The official transcript is now available in the evidence library above; use it to check precise wording and context before publishing direct quotations.

BACP complaint figures: Stakeholder posts attribute a statement about complaints concerning conversion practices to the BACP witness. Any verified figure must be reported with its complaint category, reporting period, professional jurisdiction and denominator. A statement about complaints received by one body is not a prevalence estimate for conversion practices generally.

Dr Hutchinson: Press and stakeholder reports attribute to her concerns about clinicians leaving the field and about experience of abusive practices matching the draft’s description. These are attributed accounts, not independently established workforce projections or prevalence findings. They should not be presented as verbatim parliamentary quotations without recording or transcript verification.

What follows: Review the official recording and any subsequent transcript, then compare the evidence against clauses 1–2, the conditional healthcare exclusion, the explanatory notes and the Government’s impact assessment. No Committee conclusion is inferred from individual witnesses’ evidence.

13–14 November 2026 — Schools, safeguarding and the scope of the proposed offence

Media and stakeholder commentary Reporting and commentary circulated by Sex Matters and Transgender Trend raise concerns that the proposed offence could create uncertainty for teachers, headteachers, governors and pupils when responding to gender-related issues, including safeguarding decisions. Some commentary refers to the National Education Union (NEU). These accounts do not, without original organisational statements, establish that the NEU or particular school-governance bodies have formally adopted the reported position.

Government position: In its 29 October written answer to Rosie Duffield MP, the Government said teachers and safeguarding professionals would not be criminalised merely for expressing views or holding explanatory conversations. This is an official ministerial interpretation; it does not insert a separate general safeguarding exemption into the draft.

Legal distinction: A report, safeguarding referral, police investigation, prosecution and conviction are different stages with different thresholds. Neither a disagreement about social transition nor a pupil’s ordinary question automatically meets the elements of the proposed offence. Concerns about potential investigation should be assessed separately from claims about criminal liability.

Outstanding questions: How will reasonable safeguarding decisions and parental engagement be distinguished from abusive conduct? What guidance will apply to schools, police and prosecutors? What evidence supports predicted referrals or costs? How do the draft’s proposed offences interact with existing child-protection obligations, professional standards and equality law?

13 November 2026 — Further legal commentary and newspaper reporting

Not a legislative change Sex Matters circulated a discussion involving Maya Forstater and Akua Reindorf KC and press coverage of Dr Anna Hutchinson’s evidence. These materials may inform legal scrutiny but are not official Committee conclusions or new statutory provisions. A reported statement about one clinician’s experience must not be generalised to the incidence of abusive practices.

Comparison to retain: Protect and Teach: A Minister’s Assurance Is Not a Statutory Safeguard distinguishes the Government’s description of intended safeguards from the actual draft wording. The existing detailed clause comparison below remains relevant and has not been duplicated.

Archive: verification update — 3 November 2026 (superseded by 14 November status)

Legal status: This is a draft Bill under pre-legislative scrutiny by a Joint Committee of the House of Commons and House of Lords. It has not received a First Reading, has not been enacted and does not create new offences at present. The Committee is due to report by 22 January 2027; the Government says legislation will follow when parliamentary time allows, without a fixed introduction date. Written question 30654 · 31475.

Documents now published: both 29 October panel 1 and panel 2 uncorrected transcripts (published 2 November); formal minutes to 26 October; published correspondence. The 2 November hearing took place with Deputy Jayne Ozanne OBE and Ian Smith; its uncorrected transcript was published on 3 November. A further oral-evidence hearing is listed for 12 November, with witnesses to be confirmed.

Protect and Teach’s position: The organisation opposes the draft legislation. Ministerial statements about parental choice, explanatory conversations and exploratory therapy are assurances, not express statutory exemptions. The legal test, practical safeguarding implications, proportionality and unquantified public-service costs require scrutiny. This tracker distinguishes statutory wording, published evidence, stakeholder advocacy and our interpretation.

Historical register: The entries in this section preserve the state of knowledge at the time. For current hearing dates, witnesses and legal status, see the 14 November update above.

Earlier developments — through 4 November 2026 (historical entries)

4 November — Protect and Teach evidence submitted Protect and Teach CIC has submitted written evidence to the Joint Committee. The submission has not been represented as published by Parliament. Read our announcement · Full update.

3 November — Official 2 November transcript published The uncorrected transcript records questions 58–79, including questions about family conduct, schools, religious leaders and criminal liability. Read the official transcript · Read tracker analysis.

12 November — Further hearing listed The Joint Committee has scheduled another oral-evidence hearing for Thursday 12 November, with public sessions listed from 11:15 am and 12:10 pm. Witnesses remain to be confirmed. Official hearing details.

4 November — Public campaign and competing interpretations The Telegraph’s reported campaign to scrap the Bill, reactions from LGB Alliance and others, and responses defending the draft are recorded as stakeholder and media commentary, not changes to legislation or findings of the Committee. Read the balanced evidence note.

2–3 November — Major Policy Exchange report Akua Reindorf KC and Baroness Falkner publish a 36-page critique of the draft’s definitions, criminal liability, parental safeguards, healthcare exemption, private prosecutions and human-rights implications. Full PDF report · Detailed tracker assessment.

3 November — The Times New coverage of the authors’ warning about possible prosecution of parents and human-rights compatibility. Read The Times · Read our evidence note.

2 November — Second parliamentary oral-evidence hearing completed Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith gave evidence. Reported questions from Sir Jeremy Wright KC MP, Baroness Prentis of Banbury and Naz Shah MP concerned family conduct, knowledge of harm and an 11-year-old’s request for a breast binder. The official transcript had not been published as at 3 November; clip descriptions are provisional. Official Parliament hearing · Shared video clip · Further clip · All supplied clips and detailed assessment.

29 October — Written parliamentary answer The Government answered 14 of Rosie Duffield MP’s 22 identified questions on 29–30 October, including parental choices, teachers, local authority impacts and the justice assessment; eight remained unanswered as at 3 November. No answer supplied a specific operational cost figure. Official answer · Assessment.

30 October — First oral evidence recording available The Joint Committee heard its first two witness panels on 29 October. The official parliamentary recording is available. Witnesses included Stonewall, Galop and the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition, followed by Gay Men’s Network, Sex Matters and LGB Alliance. Read the evidence and clips watch. No Committee conclusions or statutory changes are implied.

29 October — First oral-evidence hearing (pre-hearing notice; now completed) The Joint Committee’s first public session is listed from 12:15 pm UK time, with a second panel at 1:10 pm. Helen Joyce, Dennis Kavanagh and Dermot Kehoe are among the scheduled witnesses. Official hearing programme. This was the pre-hearing position; the hearing has since taken place and its recording is linked in the 30 October entry. Read the 29 October stakeholder watch.

29 October — Further stakeholder responses New statements attributed to Sex Matters/Helen Joyce, LGB Alliance, Bayswater Support, Akua Reindorf and SEEN in Health concern parents, detransition, clinical practice and the claimed legislative gap. These are positions advanced by their authors, not established findings. Details and verification status.

26–27 October — Written evidence call OPEN The Joint Committee has published its formal call for evidence. Deadline: Monday 16 November 2026. This replaces earlier tracker references saying that a public call or deadline was awaited. Read the submission update.

Protect and Teach — evidence-submission explainer Parliament Calls for Evidence on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill explains the opportunity to submit evidence. Our earlier article A Minister’s Assurance Is Not a Statutory Safeguard and the ministerial-assurance versus statutory-text comparison are already linked below.

27 October — Stakeholder publications and calls to submit Sex Matters has circulated further briefing and submission guidance, and a video featuring former Tavistock clinicians Marcus and Susan Evans. Transgender Trend has urged parents to respond, referring to the parental-rights questions. Gay Men’s Network has advanced claims about same-sex attraction among former Tavistock patients and possible chilling effects on ordinary conversations. These are attributed stakeholder claims, not Committee findings or automatic legal consequences. Read the dated stakeholder note.

28 October — Further oral evidence session listed The Joint Committee has scheduled a second public oral-evidence hearing for Monday 2 November 2026, with a public oral-evidence session listed from 4:15 pm. This was the pre-hearing listing; Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith subsequently gave evidence. Official parliamentary event. Details below.

28 October — LGB Alliance APPG engagement CEO Kate Barker-Mawjee reported discussing potential implications for young lesbians at a Portcullis House APPG meeting. This is stakeholder engagement, not formal Joint Committee evidence. Read dated entry.

27 October — Former minister comments on draft Preet Kaur Gill MP raised concerns in The Telegraph about parental discussions, possible chilling effects and the Cass Review. The Government reiterated that everyday family conversations would not be criminalised. Read attributed media report.

26 October — First public evidence witnesses confirmed Parliament has named six witnesses for Thursday 29 October, with public panels at 12:15 pm and 1:10 pm, Room 2. Full programme and watching details. These were scheduled appearances; the hearing subsequently took place.

26 October — Stakeholder commentary Sex Matters announced the programme. Further criticism attributed to @prof_curiosity1 and Lesbian Labour is logged for source verification; neither claim is presented as established legal effect. Read stakeholder note.

25 October — New Protect and Teach article Who Is Driving Conversion Practices Bans? examines the WHO’s explicit recommendation, UN and Council of Europe positions, EU policy developments, Australian legislation and the Government’s documented international comparisons. It adds ten international-policy scrutiny questions distinct from the nine in the existing Protect and Teach briefing. Read tracker summary.

24 October — Transgender Trend New reported commentary warns of additional institutional scrutiny of parents who decline to facilitate a child’s social transition. This is attributed stakeholder interpretation, not an established consequence of the draft. Read assessment.

Related NHS safeguarding context The NHS Surrey and Sussex ICB’s WellBN investigation concluded that potential harm had been caused to 78 children and young people within its scope. This is a distinct healthcare investigation, not evidence of an amendment to the Bill or proof of its expected effects. Read bounded cross-reference.

Stakeholder watch: New sourced debate recording and further attributed commentary added below. Read 24 October additions. No amendment to the draft Bill is established by these reports.

Impact assessment expanded New dedicated section below covers Government ten-year cost and benefit assumptions, the uncosted justice-system impacts, Rosie Duffield’s questions, Northern Ireland’s separate cost review, and attributed concerns raised by Sarah Phillimore and EBSWA. Jump to impact scrutiny.

  • Committee inquiry: The parliamentary inquiry is recorded as opened on 20 October. A letter from Minister Simon Lightwood, dated 13 October and published on 21 October, formally presents the draft for scrutiny. It restates Government policy; it does not amend the draft.
  • Written parliamentary questions — 22 October: Rosie Duffield asked about parents, teachers, local-authority workloads and protection-order costs, and the outstanding justice-system assessment. Responses should be checked individually against the linked parliamentary question pages; the answer to question 37255 was published on 29 October.
  • 29 October hearing: The official event record now specifies Room 2, Palace of Westminster, with private discussion from noon and public oral-evidence segments listed from approximately 12:15 pm and 1:10 pm. The six witnesses are now confirmed in the official meeting record.
  • Next: Written evidence closes 16 November at 5 pm; check the 29 October and 2 November hearings, ministerial answers and published submissions. The 26 October private meeting is a past scheduled event, not evidence of any outcome.

Status: The Bill remains a draft under pre-legislative scrutiny. No change to the law is implied by these developments.

Social-media clips and stakeholder update register — consolidated 14 November 2026

Source-linked research register This section brings together every distinct direct X post link retained in the previous tracker, together with the newer stakeholder reports supplied for 12–14 November. A post, excerpt or repost is not a separate parliamentary finding. Direct links are provided where the original URL is known; where no individual URL has been established, this is stated rather than inventing one.

12 November hearing — stakeholder live reporting and clips

  • Sex Matters: reported questions put by Lord Hope about whether sexual orientation and transgender identity should be addressed separately, and questions about the additional purpose of a criminal offence in relation to unregulated practitioners. Verification: attributed live reporting; check the full official recording before presenting the exchanges as verbatim quotations. Individual post URLs not yet supplied.
  • Transgender Trend: circulated accounts of the BACP evidence on complaints concerning conversion practices, Dr Anna Hutchinson’s concerns about possible loss of clinicians, and differences between adults and children and between LGB and transgender-related presentations. These are attributed summaries, not representative complaint statistics or findings on the Bill’s effects. Individual post URLs not yet supplied.
  • Dr Anna Hutchinson: a statement about her personal experience of practices meeting the draft description has been reported in newspaper and stakeholder coverage. This is not a population-level finding. The original complete quotation and context should be checked against the parliamentary recording.
  • Parliamentary witness list: Dr Igi Moon and Dr Alison Berner (11:15 am); Dr Lisa Morrison of BACP and Dr Anna Hutchinson (12:10 pm). Official event record.

13–14 November — schools, legal commentary and media

  • Sex Matters and Transgender Trend (14 November): reported concerns attributed to school leaders, governors and unions, including the NEU, about the relationship between the draft offence and safeguarding obligations. The existence and precise wording of any formal organisational statements remain to be verified; this entry does not attribute an institutional position to the NEU without its original publication.
  • Possible allegations against pupils: stakeholder reporting raises the possibility of complaints or investigation. That is distinct from satisfying the statutory elements of an offence or securing a conviction; the Bill remains a draft.
  • Sex Matters podcast (13 November): discussion featuring Maya Forstater and Akua Reindorf KC on the draft Bill. This is legal and campaign commentary, not a parliamentary or judicial ruling. Original episode URL not yet established.
  • Telegraph coverage (13–14 November): reporting circulated by Sex Matters includes Dr Hutchinson’s account of her experience. The original article and full parliamentary evidence should be consulted before using direct quotations.
  • Government’s contrasting position: the 29 October written answer states that ordinary explanatory conversations and compliance with safeguarding guidance are not intended to be criminalised. The question for scrutiny is how the draft’s actual provisions operate, not whether an assurance creates an express exemption.

Directly linked historical stakeholder posts and parliamentary clips

The following is a deduplicated index of direct post links contained in the original tracker. Descriptions reproduce the tracker context, not a fresh independent verification of each post’s contents. Earlier detailed analysis remains in the dated sections below.

  1. SexMattersOrg — 2 November — Second parliamentary oral-evidence hearing completed Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith gave evidence. Reported questions from Sir Jeremy Wright KC MP, Baroness Prentis of Banbury and Naz Shah MP concerned family conduct, knowledge of harm and an 11-year- Original X post
  2. MForstater — 2 November — Second parliamentary oral-evidence hearing completed Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith gave evidence. Reported questions from Sir Jeremy Wright KC MP, Baroness Prentis of Banbury and Naz Shah MP concerned family conduct, knowledge of harm and an 11-year- Original X post
  3. SexMattersOrg — 26 October — Stakeholder commentary Sex Matters announced the programme . Further criticism attributed to @prof_curiosity1 and Lesbian Labour is logged for source verification; neither claim is presented as established legal effect. Read stakeholder note . Original X post
  4. roseveniceallan — Helen Joyce — parental authority and coercive control: A video extract circulated by Venice Allan contrasts restricting a spouse’s phone access with a parent limiting a child’s phone access. The issue raised is whether the draft clearly distinguishes abusive c Original X post
  5. roseveniceallan — Additional 29 October hearing extract — Venice Allan: View the additional clip shared by Venice Allan on X . The speaker, precise wording and surrounding exchange have not yet been independently verified against the official parliamentary recording; no substan Original X post
  6. SexMattersOrg — Stakeholder reactions, not Committee findings Sex Matters shared commentary on X about the hearing; LGB Alliance highlighted Kehoe’s evidence and shared further testimony; Transgender Trend expressed concern about safeguarding and possible child-protection inv Original X post
  7. MForstater — Baroness Prentis of Banbury — families, schools and religious leaders: asked whether conduct within a family should be criminalised. Ozanne compared wrongdoing in different settings and referred to prosecutions elsewhere. Maya Forstater’s shared parliamentary Original X post
  8. treesey — Naz Shah — 11-year-old requesting a breast binder: put a hypothetical involving parents declining to purchase a binder. In the supplied account, Ozanne said it was difficult to answer in the abstract and did not give a direct answer. This is important evidence Original X post
  9. Jebadoo2 — Additional contemporaneous commentary: Jebadoo2 commentary on the report · Further linked commentary . These are commentary, not independent legal authorities. Original X post
  10. Jebadoo2 — Additional contemporaneous commentary: Jebadoo2 commentary on the report · Further linked commentary . These are commentary, not independent legal authorities. Original X post
  11. KateBMwriting — Original source: Kate Barker-Mawjee’s statement on X . This engagement is recorded as one additional LGB Alliance register entry, not as an independent research paper. Original X post
  12. SexMattersOrg — Stakeholder representations Sex Matters reported writing to the Minister seeking express parental protection; Gay Men’s Network also published a response, shared by LGB Alliance . Bayswater Support , Transgender Trend and Maya Forstater also publicly challenge Original X post
  13. MensNetwork1 — Stakeholder representations Sex Matters reported writing to the Minister seeking express parental protection; Gay Men’s Network also published a response, shared by LGB Alliance . Bayswater Support , Transgender Trend and Maya Forstater also publicly challenge Original X post
  14. AllianceLGB — Stakeholder representations Sex Matters reported writing to the Minister seeking express parental protection; Gay Men’s Network also published a response, shared by LGB Alliance . Bayswater Support , Transgender Trend and Maya Forstater also publicly challenge Original X post
  15. BayswaterSG — Stakeholder representations Sex Matters reported writing to the Minister seeking express parental protection; Gay Men’s Network also published a response, shared by LGB Alliance . Bayswater Support , Transgender Trend and Maya Forstater also publicly challenge Original X post
  16. Transgendertrd — Stakeholder representations Sex Matters reported writing to the Minister seeking express parental protection; Gay Men’s Network also published a response, shared by LGB Alliance . Bayswater Support , Transgender Trend and Maya Forstater also publicly challenge Original X post
  17. MForstater — Stakeholder representations Sex Matters reported writing to the Minister seeking express parental protection; Gay Men’s Network also published a response, shared by LGB Alliance . Bayswater Support , Transgender Trend and Maya Forstater also publicly challenge Original X post
  18. ABarrosCurtis — Alex Barros-Curtis MP: 31 August 2026: signed EDM 240 seeking disapproval of the proposed EHRC services code. In a public statement of 31 July and ministerial letter dated 30 July , raised concerns over trans people’s access to services and identified stakehol Original X post
  19. Transgendertrd — Transgender Trend post · Children of Transitioners post · Background account Original X post
  20. ChildrenOfTrans — Transgender Trend post · Children of Transitioners post · Background account Original X post
  21. Transgendertrd — Stakeholder report Transgender Trend reported that a Battle of Ideas discussion about the draft Bill attracted a large audience and expressed concern about possible effects on safeguarding, family relationships and free expression. This is the organisation’s a Original X post
  22. AllianceLGB — Stakeholder advocacy LGB Alliance has continued publishing video testimonies opposing the draft Bill. These may inform scrutiny of personal experiences and predicted impacts, but do not themselves establish the legal consequences of the proposed clauses. LGB A Original X post
  23. AllianceLGB — 20 October stakeholder developments Sex Matters’ letter requests explicit protection for parents; Gay Men’s Network’s response challenges the Minister’s article, and LGB Alliance’s further testimony video records an individual account. These are advocacy and t Original X post
  24. OurDutyUK — September 2026 · Circulated 12 October 2026 · Parent guide Tell them the truth — A Parent’s Briefing Four-image briefing discussing the absence of a general parental exemption, concerns about family decision-making, protection orders, allegations and possible Original X post

Register methodology: Links to profiles without a specific post, descriptions of clips for which no URL was supplied, and duplicate references to the same post are not counted as separate linked posts. Stakeholder allegations, media accounts and formal parliamentary evidence remain separately labelled.

5 November 2026 — Protect and Teach CIC submission (original announcement published 4 November)

Protect and Teach submission Protect and Teach CIC confirms that it has submitted written evidence to the Joint Committee scrutinising the Draft Conversion Practices Bill (England and Wales). The organisation opposes the draft in its present form and has already published extensive separate research and policy analysis.

Read Protect and Teach’s 4 November announcement · Read the existing evidence review and policy analysis.

New — 20 November Five Parliamentary Hearings, but Where Is the Evidence That New Criminal Law Is Needed? — a separate published analysis of the oral evidence and its relationship to our September review. This is not the unpublished organisational written submission.

Publication distinction: The submission has been sent to the Committee; it should not be described as accepted, endorsed or published by Parliament unless the official evidence register confirms that status. The previously published review and articles are separate from the written submission.

3–4 November 2026 — Official transcript of 2 November hearing available

Official parliamentary record The Joint Committee published its uncorrected transcript of the 2 November hearing with Deputy Jayne Ozanne OBE and Ian Smith on 3 November. It covers questions 58–79. At Q68 Baroness Prentis asked whether the proposed legislation could extend to parents, schools and individual religious leaders, challenging the distinction between criminalisation and prosecution. The testimony is evidence of witnesses’ views and questions, not a Committee finding about the law’s eventual application.

Read the full official 2 November transcript · Official publications register.

Next hearing: Thursday 12 November 2026; private meeting from 11 am, public sessions listed at 11:15 am and 12:10 pm, witnesses to be confirmed. Official event listing. Written evidence closes 16 November at 5 pm.

4 November 2026 — Newspaper campaign and stakeholder responses

Public debate — not a legislative amendment The Telegraph has reportedly launched a campaign to scrap the draft Bill, raising concerns about the potential chilling effect on parents and children and possible implications of the age of criminal responsibility. Support has been reported from LGB Alliance and other critics. The proposition that a particular conversation by a 10-year-old would constitute an offence is a contested interpretation, not an established prosecution outcome; any liability would depend on the final statutory elements and evidence.

Akua Reindorf KC’s public commentary has raised concerns about the potential reach of the proposed offence into family life and professional safeguarding decisions. Sex Matters has separately highlighted scenarios involving families. These are legal and policy arguments advanced by their authors.

Alternative interpretation: Supporters of the draft, including Sappho in reported commentary, maintain that it is intended to target serious coercive conduct rather than ordinary conversations. The Government has also defended the proposed threshold. The critical scrutiny question remains whether the actual statutory text delivers the protections described in public assurances.

Evidence status: The reported Telegraph campaign, remarks attributed to politicians and stakeholder media clips require checking against their original publications before direct quotations are added. The British Psychological Society’s separately reported consultation deadline should also be independently confirmed; it is distinct from the Joint Committee’s confirmed 16 November deadline.

Parliamentary status recorded on 4 November 2026 (historical snapshot)

The Government published the Draft Conversion Practices Bill on 25 June 2026. It remains a draft undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny, not an enacted law. The 12-member Joint Committee must report by 22 January 2027.

Chair: Alex Barros-Curtis MP, recorded as taking the Chair on 12 October 2026. Members’ previous statements and selected division records are set out below; no member has yet voted on the draft Bill itself.

Parliament lists private meetings on 12 October (4–6 pm), 15 October (12–1:30 pm), 19 October (4–6 pm), and further private meetings for 22 October (12–1:30 pm) and 26 October (4–6 pm). Oral-evidence sessions took place on 29 October (two public panels with six witnesses) and 2 November (Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith). A private listing is not a public oral-evidence hearing. The Committee has since opened its public call for written evidence, with a 16 November 2026 deadline.

Parliamentary developments recorded on 4 November 2026

Chair identified 12 October: Alex Barros-Curtis MP takes the Chair. His 25 June Commons comments welcomed progress towards a ban and said he had spoken extensively with the Minister. His prior statements are included in the member register below.

Committee diary Private meetings listed for 12 October (4–6pm, Room 4), 15 October (12–1:30pm, Room 4), 19 October (4–6pm, Room 4), 22 October (12–1:30pm, Room 4) and 26 October (4–6pm, Room 2, Palace of Westminster). 29 October (12–3pm) is listed as an oral-evidence session; the six witnesses have since been named. The published formal minutes record decisions at private meetings; the oral-evidence transcripts establish what was said in the 29 October hearing.

Membership The 18 September announcement and membership page list six MPs and six peers, including Naz Shah MP. Earlier commentary carrying a different member list should not be treated as current.

Written evidence open Formal call published; submissions close 16 November 2026. Still awaited Published written evidence and eventual Committee report. The 2 November uncorrected transcript was published on 3 November. Both 29 October transcripts were published on 2 November. Contact: draftbills@parliament.uk.

29–30 October 2026 — First oral evidence heard: recording and selected clips

Official parliamentary evidence The Joint Committee held its first public oral-evidence hearing on 29 October 2026. Panel one heard Stephen Kiely (Stonewall), Kai O’Doherty (Galop) and Professor Ilias Trispiotis (Ban Conversion Practices Coalition). Panel two heard Dennis Kavanagh (Gay Men’s Network), Helen Joyce (Sex Matters) and Dermot Kehoe (LGB Alliance). Watch the full official Parliament Live recording · Official Committee meeting record.

Selected extracts and issues for scrutiny

  • Helen Joyce — parental authority and coercive control: A video extract circulated by Venice Allan contrasts restricting a spouse’s phone access with a parent limiting a child’s phone access. The issue raised is whether the draft clearly distinguishes abusive control from reasonable parental decisions. Watch the extract shared by Venice Allan on X. The surrounding exchange remains to be checked against Parliament Live.
  • Dermot Kehoe — parents, same-sex attraction and gender identity: LGB Alliance circulated a reported example of a parent saying they believe their child is gay rather than “born in the wrong body”. This illustrates the organisation’s concern about the scope of prohibited intentions and ordinary family discussions. Original LGB Alliance clip URL and complete context await verification.
  • Additional 29 October hearing extract — Venice Allan: View the additional clip shared by Venice Allan on X. The speaker, precise wording and surrounding exchange have not yet been independently verified against the official parliamentary recording; no substantive claim is attributed to this clip pending that check.
  • Dennis Kavanagh — clarity of the proposed offence: Neil O’Brien MP reportedly shared an extract of Kavanagh warning about possible criminalisation of normal family debates. This is a witness’s legal concern, not a finding that ordinary discussion is itself an offence; direct Neil O’Brien clip URL awaits verification.

Stakeholder reactions, not Committee findings Sex Matters shared commentary on X about the hearing; LGB Alliance highlighted Kehoe’s evidence and shared further testimony; Transgender Trend expressed concern about safeguarding and possible child-protection investigations; and For Women Scotland criticised a comparison attributed to Professor Trispiotis. Rosie Duffield MP separately criticised the choice of Committee Chair. These accounts and reactions should not be confused with the official transcript or a Committee determination. Where direct post links are unavailable, this tracker links to the full parliamentary recording rather than inventing clip links.

Protect and Teach assessment: The hearing raises questions about parental responsibility, professional judgement, the proposed offence’s legal certainty, existing safeguarding law and the potential chilling effect of investigation or prosecution. Protect and Teach opposes the draft Bill; opposition to this draft does not excuse abusive or coercive conduct. Any prediction of criminal liability must be tested against the full statutory elements and available safeguards.

Still to verify Official transcript, exact clip timestamps, remaining original social-media clip URLs, subsequent witness correspondence and written evidence. Written evidence remains open until 5 pm on 16 November 2026; a further public hearing is listed for 2 November. The draft has not been enacted.

29 October 2026 — First oral evidence and latest stakeholder commentary

Numbered register: 37 entries across 12 organisations (last counted 29 October 2026; 30 October hearing reactions tracked separately). Counts include explicitly labelled statements, reposts and contextual material where listed; they do not all represent independent research publications. The separate 29 October stakeholder watch is excluded pending original-source verification.

Parliamentary schedule The Joint Committee’s first public oral-evidence hearing is scheduled today from 12:15 pm, with the second panel listed at 1:10 pm. The witnesses and panel affiliations are set out in the official programme section. Official Committee event and viewing information. Statements made before the hearing should not be represented as oral testimony.

Sex Matters / Helen Joyce Helen Joyce, a scheduled witness, reportedly described the draft as a “slow-motion disaster” for trans-identifying children in her newsletter, arguing that parental safeguards are threatened. The exact newsletter and individual social-post URLs have not been independently verified for this entry; the description is attributed commentary, not a Committee finding.

LGB Alliance The organisation argues that the proposed regime could discourage support for detransition, including support from parents, clinicians and therapists, because of the prospect of investigation. This is a predicted chilling effect, not a determination that such support is an offence.

Bayswater Support Bayswater reportedly alleges that false conversion-practice accusations have been made against parents, the Cass Review and NHS gender services. The prevalence and circumstances of those allegations have not been independently established in this tracker.

Akua Reindorf / For Women Scotland Akua Reindorf has reportedly questioned the legal gap the proposed offence is intended to fill; For Women Scotland circulated her commentary. The key question for scrutiny is which conduct is not already covered by existing criminal, safeguarding or civil law and whether the proposed measures are necessary and proportionate. A repost is not a separate independent analysis.

SEEN in Health / Gay Men’s Network SEEN in Health circulated the official hearing link and endorsed a Gay Men’s Network critique concerning possible consequences for sex-based clinical conversations. Dennis Kavanagh also circulated Sex Matters’ rebuttal of evidence used to justify the Bill. These are stakeholder assessments of potential legal and professional risks; the actual statutory elements and clinical exclusions require clause-specific scrutiny.

Other reported activity Labour Women’s Declaration recommended Julie Bindel’s interviews as background reading; Rosie Duffield MP reportedly referred to a further meeting. These are engagement or commentary, not legislative amendments or Joint Committee evidence. Individual original links and dates remain to be verified.

Scope boundary: The Hampstead Ponds intervention decision, NHS Fife/Sandie Peggie reporting, Brighton Withdean pool redesign and reported NHS Wales gender-service referral changes are separate legal, healthcare or facilities matters. They are not changes to this draft Bill. Any NHS Wales suspension, its extent and reasons require confirmation from an authoritative NHS source before being recorded as fact.

Publication-count rule: This dated watch note is not added to the numbered stakeholder-publication totals until distinct original publications, links and dates are verified and entered in the appropriate organisation’s expandable register. A hearing appearance, repost or social-media engagement statistic is not automatically a new research publication.

27 October 2026 — Joint Committee written evidence call now open

Confirmed parliamentary process The Joint Committee has formally invited written evidence on the draft Bill, including its scope, definitions, operation and safeguards. Deadline: Monday 16 November 2026. The Committee is due to report by 22 January 2027. The draft has not become law and the call does not alter its wording.

Official source: Joint Committee — call for evidence and submission instructions.

Protect and Teach publication Parliament Calls for Evidence on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill. Readers should use the official parliamentary page for the submission process and deadline.

Key scrutiny distinction: Bridget Phillipson’s 18 October assurances, the Government’s explanatory notes and stakeholder descriptions are not substitutes for statutory wording. See the existing clause-by-clause assurance comparison.

27 October 2026 — Stakeholder evidence and campaigning watch

Sex Matters A further briefing concerning who might face criminalisation, practical guidance on submitting evidence, and a video featuring former Tavistock clinicians Marcus and Susan Evans have been reported. Their concerns about family discussions, clinical practice and possible chilling effects are stakeholder interpretations. Criminalisation-risk briefing (other individual publication URLs and dates still require confirmation).

Transgender Trend The organisation is urging parents to submit evidence, directing attention to the parental-rights section and question 12 of the Committee’s call. This is campaign guidance, not a Committee conclusion. Check the official questions and submission instructions. The direct campaign post remains to be verified.

Gay Men’s Network The organisation reportedly claims that 80–90% of Tavistock patients were same-sex attracted and warns of possible criminalisation of reassurance to a teenager that they may be gay. The percentage is not verified here as a representative clinical statistic, and the suggested criminal-law outcome is an advocacy interpretation: any offence would require the statutory elements to be proved. The original statement and supporting denominator/methodology should be checked before presenting the percentage as established fact.

29 October hearing Parliament has scheduled Stonewall, Galop and the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition at 12:15 pm, followed by Gay Men’s Network, Sex Matters and LGB Alliance at 1:10 pm. Official meeting and watch information. This was the position when this 27 October note was written; the hearing took place on 29 October.

Scope: Reporting concerning NHS Fife/Sandie Peggie and Stirling Council licensing is not a legislative development in this draft Bill and is not included in its parliamentary update.

Record status (3 November): The 29 October uncorrected evidence is now available in Panel 1 and Panel 2. The 2 November transcript was not yet published. See the current verification update for superseding status.

2 November 2026 — Second public oral-evidence session: Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith

Hearing completed The Joint Committee heard evidence from Deputy Jayne Ozanne OBE, a campaigner for conversion-practices legislation, and Ian Smith on Monday 2 November. The public session was listed from 4:15 pm in Room 3, Palace of Westminster. Their evidence should be assessed against the proposed statutory tests rather than treated as a definitive account of how a future court would apply the legislation.

Primary parliamentary source: Official Committee meeting and parliamentary video.

Questions and recorded exchanges requiring particular scrutiny

  • Sir Jeremy Wright KC MP — practical effect of the legislation: asked what difference the proposed offence would have made to Ozanne. She discussed larger organisations, repeated conduct and the potential deterrent effect on people acting with good intentions. Sex Matters’ clip and account of the parliamentary exchange.
  • Baroness Prentis of Banbury — families, schools and religious leaders: asked whether conduct within a family should be criminalised. Ozanne compared wrongdoing in different settings and referred to prosecutions elsewhere. Maya Forstater’s shared parliamentary clip/commentary.
  • Naz Shah — 11-year-old requesting a breast binder: put a hypothetical involving parents declining to purchase a binder. In the supplied account, Ozanne said it was difficult to answer in the abstract and did not give a direct answer. This is important evidence of an unresolved practical boundary, not proof that refusal would itself satisfy the proposed criminal offence. Shared parliamentary extract and account · Additional clip.
  • Naz Shah — knowledge of harm: asked whether people responsible for distress ought to have known their conduct would cause harm. The exchange included comments about prayer and distress. Shared extract.

Additional contemporaneous commentary: Jebadoo2 commentary on the report · Further linked commentary. These are commentary, not independent legal authorities.

Source distinction: The footage derives from the parliamentary session and is primary evidence of what witnesses said. Social-media captions and legal interpretations remain attributable to their respective publishers. For quotations, readers should consult the official full recording for context. A separate written transcript is not a prerequisite for citing the recording.

Protect and Teach assessment: The exchanges raise questions about the boundaries of parental responsibility, reasonable safeguarding decisions, religious activity, criminal intent and the potential chilling effect of investigations. Witness assurances cannot insert exemptions that do not appear in the draft legislation.

2–3 November 2026 — Policy Exchange legal report: Not What It Says On The Tin

Published legal analysis Policy Exchange published Not What It Says On The Tin: Report on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill 2026, a 36-page report by Akua Reindorf KC (former EHRC commissioner) and Baroness Kishwer Falkner (former EHRC chair). This is a substantial new independent policy/legal critique, not an EHRC institutional position, court judgment or amendment to the draft Bill.

Read the complete Policy Exchange PDF report · Policy Exchange publication page.

Clause-specific concerns examined by the authors

  • Clause 1 — definitions: uncertainty about the scope of “conduct”, “transgender identity” and “abusive” conduct, including non-exhaustive statutory examples.
  • Clause 1(3) — healthcare: whether the conditional healthcare exclusion gives clinicians and therapists sufficient certainty, particularly when exploring a child’s distress.
  • Clause 2 — principal offence: the distinction between intending to influence sexual orientation or transgender identity and intending or foreseeing abusive conduct or harm. The report characterises the latter as a major defect. Careful distinction: the draft does contain an intention requirement in clause 1; the authors’ objection is that it does not separately require intention to cause abuse or harm.
  • Parents and children: the lack of an express general parental exemption, the application of the ordinary age of criminal responsibility and hypothetical decisions about breast binders or privately funded treatment. A parental refusal does not automatically amount to a criminal offence; all statutory elements would still have to be established.
  • Clause 5 — bodies and officers: the proposed duties and possible organisational liability, including implications for schools, charities and faith organisations.
  • Private prosecutions and defences: the report questions the availability of private proceedings and the absence of a general express statutory defence of reasonableness.
  • Protection orders and wider law: proposed preventive orders, interaction with family and equality law, and the authors’ concerns under ECHR Articles 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14.
  • Evidence and necessity: the authors challenge the Government’s prevalence estimates and argue that much of the most serious conduct is already prohibited by existing criminal law. Their criticisms of research methods and the claimed remaining legislative gap require separate assessment against original studies and the Government’s impact assessment.

Protect and Teach assessment: The report adds detailed legal arguments to concerns already identified in our analysis about child safeguarding, parental responsibilities, legal certainty, the availability of exploratory therapy, criminal justice costs and potential chilling effects. Its conclusions are the authors’ arguments, not findings by the Joint Committee. The central test remains whether ministerial assurances are matched by clear statutory protections.

3 November 2026 — The Times reports legal warning about parents and human rights

Newspaper coverage of substantive legal report The Times reports concerns raised by Akua Reindorf KC and Baroness Falkner that the draft offence could expose parents to criminal investigation or prosecution in certain disputes about a child’s gender-related decisions, and that provisions may face human-rights challenges. These are reported legal concerns about a draft law, not an established criminal outcome or a judicial declaration of incompatibility.

Read The Times report · Read the underlying full Policy Exchange report.

Government position: Ministers maintain that ordinary parenting and appropriate professional conversations are not the intended target of the draft offence. The relevant issue is whether the proposed statutory language makes the boundaries sufficiently clear, including in cases of family disagreement, and whether the serious-harm and abuse tests provide adequate protection.

Further public discussion: Commentary on the authors’ warning · Related post. These are stakeholder reactions rather than additional legal reports.

Record status (3 November): The 29 October uncorrected evidence is now available in Panel 1 and Panel 2. The 2 November transcript was not yet published. See the current verification update for superseding status.

29 October 2026 — Government written answer on teachers and social transition

Official parliamentary answer In response to Rosie Duffield MP’s question about a teacher declining to support a pupil’s social transition, the Government stated that teachers and safeguarding professionals would not be criminalised merely for expressing views or engaging in explanatory conversations, and referred to the proposed tests concerning abusive conduct and serious harm. This is a formal Government interpretation of the draft, not a new statutory exemption.

Read written question 37255 and the official answer. Other Duffield questions on parents, protection orders and public-sector costs are linked in the impact assessment section; readers should check their individual answer dates and texts.

1–3 November 2026 — Stakeholder monitoring: parental rights, evidence and campaigning

Attributed stakeholder activity The following developments are recorded as leads from stakeholder monitoring. They are not amendments to the draft Bill or formal Joint Committee findings; a social-media repost is not counted as a separate research paper.

  • Sex Matters: promoted the Policy Exchange report and The Times coverage, highlighted the 2 November parliamentary exchanges, and discussed polling about public support for prosecuting parents. Poll percentages should not be quoted until the survey question, sample and methodology have been checked. Parliamentary clip shared by Sex Matters.
  • Transgender Trend: promoted the #BinTheBill campaign and raised concerns about parental responses to family-court investigations, the scope of protection orders and whether parents or schools could feel pressured to affirm. These are legal-risk arguments requiring clause-specific assessment.
  • LGB Alliance: promoted an open letter from families opposing the draft Bill and invited signatures. This is public campaigning, not itself evidence submitted to the Joint Committee.
  • Bayswater Support: continued to highlight parents’ concerns and wider gender-service safeguarding questions. The PATHWAYS trial and Levy Review are relevant clinical context but are not changes to this Bill.
  • Stonewall, Galop and the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition: their 29 October evidence is part of the official record; their arguments in favour of or for strengthening legislation must be assessed alongside those opposing the draft.
  • Comparative legislation: commentary on Australian conversion-practices bans, including an interview with Tess Hackett, may inform scrutiny but must distinguish different jurisdictions, offence definitions and enforcement mechanisms.

Scope boundary: Hampstead Ponds litigation, the Bristol City Council settlement, London rough-sleeping fund eligibility, NHS mastectomy statistics and PATHWAYS trial publications should be monitored separately. They do not, by themselves, constitute parliamentary developments in this draft Bill.

28 October 2026 — LGB Alliance discusses young lesbians at APPG meeting

Stakeholder parliamentary engagement Kate Barker-Mawjee, Chief Executive of LGB Alliance, reported attending an All-Party Parliamentary Group meeting at Portcullis House to discuss the possible implications of the Draft Conversion Practices Bill for young lesbians. LGB Alliance separately argued that young lesbians could be particularly affected and referred to Rosie Duffield MP.

These are attributed stakeholder assessments. The precise APPG has not been identified from the supplied statements, and this was not the Joint Committee’s formal oral-evidence session.

Original source: Kate Barker-Mawjee’s statement on X. This engagement is recorded as one additional LGB Alliance register entry, not as an independent research paper.

27 October 2026 — Preet Kaur Gill MP raises concerns in newspaper interview

Attributed media interview, not Committee evidence In an interview reported by Cameron Henderson in The Telegraph, former health minister Preet Kaur Gill MP said she had serious concerns about the draft Bill, particularly whether provisions concerning economic and emotional pressure could discourage legitimate parental discussions about gender-related medical interventions. She invoked the Cass Review and warned of a possible chilling effect on family conversations. The article also quoted criticism from shadow equalities minister Joy Morrissey MP.

Government response: A spokesperson maintained that the draft sets a high threshold involving abuse and serious psychological or physical harm and would not affect ordinary family conversations. These competing interpretations do not establish how the proposed offences would be applied; the statutory wording and all routes to liability require examination.

Source: Cameron Henderson, Labour backlash over conversion therapy ban, 27 October 2026. A social-media repost of this interview is not counted as a separate stakeholder publication.

26 October 2026 — First public oral-evidence witnesses and times confirmed

Official parliamentary programme The Joint Committee has published the witness list for Thursday 29 October 2026 in Room 2, Palace of Westminster. The meeting begins with private discussion at noon, followed by two public panels; a further private discussion is listed at 2 pm.

12:15 pm — First public panel

  • Stephen Kiely — Head of Policy and Public Affairs, Stonewall
  • Kai O’Doherty — Director of Policy and Research, Galop
  • Professor Ilias Trispiotis — Member of the Steering Group, Ban Conversion Practices Coalition

1:10 pm — Second public panel

  • Dennis Kavanagh — Director, Gay Men’s Network
  • Helen Joyce — Director of Advocacy, Sex Matters
  • Dermot Kehoe — Vice Chair, LGB Alliance

Watch and follow: Official meeting and watch link · Parliament Live guide · Sex Matters’ stakeholder announcement.

Timing clarification: Parliament lists public panels at 12:15 pm and 1:10 pm. A circulated Sex Matters post includes a different start time; for attendance or streaming, consult the official meeting record. Timings may change.

After the session The official recording was added on 30 October; check for an evidence transcript, witness submissions and exact remarks as published. A named witness’s appearance is not evidence of the position they ultimately express on each provision.

26 October 2026 — Additional stakeholder commentary

Sex Matters Published the two-panel witness programme. The official Parliament listing supplies authoritative times and witness roles. This is a meeting announcement, not a substantive research publication.

Further reported criticism Commentary attributed to @prof_curiosity1 argues that the draft could adversely affect parents and therapists who adopt a cautious or watchful-waiting approach. Lesbian Labour has reportedly described the draft as an attack on childhood. These are stakeholder characterisations; the original source URLs have not been verified and the statements are not findings about statutory effect.

Analytical distinction: The draft does not automatically criminalise parental disagreement, a watchful-waiting approach or exploratory discussion. Assessment of potential liability requires the actual statutory tests and context. Potential indirect effects on professional and family decision-making remain a subject for scrutiny.

Related new publication: Galop, 20 October 2026 — Scrutiny Begins on the draft Conversion Practices Bill. Galop supports a prohibition but argues that the draft needs strengthening. Its frontline case examples are not a representative national prevalence estimate.

15–21 October 2026 — Committee diary update

Official announcement On 15 October, the Joint Committee formally announced that it had appointed Alex Barros-Curtis MP as Chair. It said the Committee would meet regularly until Christmas and would publish a call for evidence and a programme of oral-evidence sessions in due course. Neither an evidence deadline nor witness list was announced in that notice.

Meeting listed The Committee’s third private meeting was listed for 19 October, 4–6 pm, Room 4, Palace of Westminster. Further private meetings are listed for 22 October, 12–1:30 pm, Room 4 and 26 October, 4–6 pm, Room 2, Palace of Westminster. A scheduled private meeting does not establish any decision or published proceedings.

Sources: Committee announcement, 15 October · Official Committee meeting diary · Committee homepage.

Oral evidence listed Parliament’s 29 October event listing gives Thursday 29 October 2026, 12–3 pm for an oral-evidence session. At this check, six witnesses and Room 2 are now confirmed on the official meeting page. This is a scheduled hearing, not evidence already received.

18–21 October 2026 — Ministerial assurances, the draft text and stakeholder responses

Ministerial commentary On 18 October, Bridget Phillipson defended the Government’s proposals in The Independent, giving assurances about parents, legitimate conversations and the serious-harm test. A ministerial newspaper article is not an enacted exemption or a substitute for the text Parliament may ultimately pass.

Protect and Teach analysis Protect and Teach published A Minister’s Assurance Is Not a Statutory Safeguard on 19 October. Its analysis compares those assurances with the draft provisions. The link is provided for publication cross-reference; readers should check the live article if the website slug changes.

  • Parents: the draft does not contain a general express exemption for parents. That does not mean parental disagreement is automatically an offence; all statutory elements would still need to be satisfied.
  • Abuse: clause 1 provides a contextual assessment, including psychological or emotional pressure, rather than importing a single closed definition from domestic-abuse legislation.
  • Consequences: clause 2 includes an alternative route involving serious alarm or distress with a substantial adverse effect on usual day-to-day activities, not solely serious physical or psychological harm.
  • Protection orders: the proposed civil preventative regime requires separate scrutiny, including circumstances in which a prior criminal conviction is not required.
  • Healthcare: the exclusion is conditional and tied to standards reasonably expected of the provider.

Stakeholder representations Sex Matters reported writing to the Minister seeking express parental protection; Gay Men’s Network also published a response, shared by LGB Alliance. Bayswater Support, Transgender Trend and Maya Forstater also publicly challenged aspects of the Minister’s account. These are attributed stakeholder arguments, not findings by the Joint Committee.

Protect and Teach’s recommendation remains that the draft Bill should be withdrawn. Government draft Bill · Explanatory Notes.

21–23 October — Ministerial correspondence and parliamentary questions

Published correspondence The Joint Committee published Simon Lightwood MP’s letter to Chair Alex Barros-Curtis on 21 October (letter dated 13 October). The Minister describes the Government’s intention to prohibit abusive conversion practices while respecting freedom of religion, parental rights and appropriate healthcare. These are ministerial assertions about the draft’s intended balance; the letter does not add a statutory parental exemption or change any clause.

Written answers awaited On 22 October, Rosie Duffield MP tabled questions on parental refusal to support transition (37254), teachers and social transition (37255), the Minister’s terminology (37256), local-authority burdens and protection orders (37257), and justice-system cost assessment (37268). Questions do not establish that a Government answer has been given. Update, 3 November: Fourteen of 22 identified questions had been answered; see the verified question audit.

Next verification: Check the answers as they are published and assess whether they supply a substantive definition, safeguard, impact estimate or commitment, rather than treating ministerial assurances as changes to the Bill.

Devolved governments: chronology and territorial extent

Clause 6 currently provides for England and Wales only. No extension to Scotland or Northern Ireland has been enacted or agreed through this draft. In the 22 October letter, Scottish Government director John Somers said ministers were committed to working constructively with the UK Government to explore extension to Scotland after scrutiny, emphasising a coherent approach. The letter records a 2024 Scottish consultation receiving 5,811 responses; it does not commit Scotland to the Bill.

On 29 October, Joint Committee Chair Alex Barros-Curtis MP wrote separately to Scottish minister Simita Kumar MSP, Welsh minister Sioned Williams MS and Northern Ireland minister Gordon Lyons MLA, asking about Clause 6, divergence, practical effects and potential evidence from ministers or officials. As at 3 November, no replies to those three 29 October letters had been published. The Scottish 22 October letter predates the Chair’s request and must not be represented as its reply. No equivalent Welsh position should be inferred without an actual response. Northern Ireland has a separate Assembly legislative process.

Official Committee correspondence register · Formal minutes.

Stakeholder evidence and research — consolidated update, 3 November

Stonewall: LGBTQ+ Life in the UK: 2026

The Stonewall/YouGov report surveyed 3,473 LGBTQ+ adults online from 25 March to 27 April 2026. It reports 1% ever underwent conversion practices and a further 4% were offered but did not undergo them. Stephen Kiely’s 29 October evidence broadly reflects these figures; “offered but not undergone” must not be confused with the total ever offered or undergone. Trans-women (n=74) and trans-men (n=61) subgroup figures require the report’s caution about bases below 100. The denominator for the report’s “who offered” breakdown is not stated in the reviewed material; do not present inferred sample sizes as fact. The 2017 national survey used different definitions, so direct trend claims are unsafe.

Galop and survivors’ testimony

Galop and witnesses supporting stronger restrictions describe serious coercion, psychological abuse and harmful experiences. The Humanists UK account of 2 November evidence describes Ian Smith’s and Deputy Jayne Ozanne OBE’s reported experiences. Their testimony is important evidence of individual experiences, but the Committee’s official 2 November transcript had not been published at the check; specific quotes, member challenges and attributed legal proposals remain provisional. Galop’s cited 51% religious, 19% healthcare and 16% family-setting figures require verification against their underlying source and denominator.

Sex Matters, LGB Alliance, Gay Men’s Network and other critics

The 2 November Sex Matters commentary argues that ministerial assurances do not adequately protect non-affirming parents and exploratory conversations. The 29 October official second-panel transcript records evidence from Sex Matters, Gay Men’s Network and LGB Alliance; claims about foreseeable chilling effects, detransition and existing criminal law are witness submissions, not Committee findings. The Policy Exchange paper by Akua Reindorf KC and Baroness Falkner offers a critical legal and policy analysis; its conclusions should be attributed to its authors rather than described as judicial findings.

Supporters of broader prohibition

The 29 October first-panel transcript records Stonewall, Galop and Professor Ilias Trispiotis, including proposals concerning the meaning of suppression, the distinction between abusive and non-abusive practices and healthcare exclusions. These are arguments for the Committee to assess, not amendments already accepted. The different stakeholder positions are retained in the detailed historical register below.

Methodological distinction: Stonewall’s 2026 lifetime 1% undergone measure and the Government impact assessment’s estimated 4.2%–5.2% annual prevalence arise from different questions, samples and definitions. They cannot be directly equated; their divergence is a reason for further methodological scrutiny, not proof that either is necessarily false.

Impact assessment: quantified and unquantified costs

The published draft final-stage economic impact assessment estimates £45.8 million in one-off public-sector familiarisation costs (best estimate; £24.9m–£82.8m range). Its preferred-option ten-year estimate is £59.7 million (range £33.2m–£103.3m), expressly excluding wider criminal justice system costs. The assessment states that those impacts are still being assessed with the Ministry of Justice.

Selected public-sector familiarisation estimates: education £36.6m; police £3.7m; healthcare £3.3m; social workers £1.6m; CPS £0.2m; HMCTS £0.2m. These are training/familiarisation assumptions, not estimates of investigation, prosecution, protection-order applications, family proceedings, prison/probation, legal aid, child-protection inquiries, placements or future casework. No reliable aggregate for these omitted activities is established by the published figures.

The impact assessment’s £783m monetised benefits and £724m net present social value are modelled estimates, not observed outcomes. The review also identifies an annual prevalence estimate of 75,000–93,000 derived from selected 2025 survey items; the underlying question definitions and uncertainty must accompany any quotation.

Clause-by-clause safeguard audit — 3 November 2026

Clause 1(2): defines conduct undertaken with the intention of causing a person to have, not have, or believe they have or do not have a sexual orientation or transgender identity. Clause 1(3): conditionally excludes conduct in the course of providing healthcare services to the individual, unless it falls far below standards reasonably expected of a person in that position. Clause 1(5)–(6): requires assessment of abuse on the facts, including violence, coercion and psychological or emotional pressure. Clause 2: the principal criminal offence additionally requires specified serious harm or serious alarm/distress with substantial adverse effects. These are distinct cumulative elements; the healthcare standard is not a universal test for all conduct. Official draft Bill · Explanatory Notes.

No express blanket exemption for parents, teachers, safeguarding decisions, prayer or non-healthcare exploratory conversations was identified in the text reviewed. This does not establish that every disagreement or discussion would be criminal: the offence thresholds remain material. The healthcare exclusion is conditional and depends on whether the conduct qualifies as healthcare services to the individual. The Bill does not state a minimum age for its protection, and the principal offence wording does not expressly require intent to cause the resulting harm.

Protection orders require separate scrutiny. The Schedule allows applications by individuals, police and local authorities, and orders may arise in specified family or criminal proceedings, including without-notice orders. These mechanisms do not require a prior conviction for the principal offence; breach without reasonable excuse is separately criminalised. Safeguarding, family-court proportionality, due process and public-service costs therefore need assessment in their own right.

Apparent drafting inconsistencies, not settled legal findings: the verification review flags several possible erroneous Schedule cross-references (including appeals in paragraph 7, paragraph 9 terminology, and references in paragraphs 6 and 12), and differences in wording between the offence and protection-order harm tests. These should be checked and clarified by Parliamentary Counsel; the tracker does not assume the intended correction.

Parliamentary written questions — verified audit at 3 November 2026

Rosie Duffield MP tabled 22 relevant questions: 17 on 22 October, one on 26 October and four on 28 October. Fourteen had published answers (29–30 October); eight had no published answer at the time of checking. “Answered” does not mean the requested figure, definition or assessment was provided.

Question(s)What the published answer establishedWhat remains unresolved
37254; 3725529 October: ministerial assurances on parental choices, explanatory conversations and teachers/safeguarding professionals; reference to KCSIE.No express parent or teacher exclusion identified; the specific decision not to facilitate social transition was not answered in terms.
3725629 October: description of the proposed offence.No direct definition of “living as their true self” or examples.
37257, 37258, 37259, 3727029 October: reliance on the draft economic assessment and future updates.No individual estimate of local authority workload, protection-order legal costs, social care referrals or capacity.
37266, 37271, 3727229 October: general references to stakeholder engagement.No clear yes/no on consultation with councils/LGA/WLGA, or detail of representations received.
37268, 3727829–30 October: work with the Ministry of Justice on the Justice Impact Test.No publication date or quantified justice-system impacts.
37276, 3727729 October: future assessment updates indicated.No figures for family proceedings or legal aid.
37273, 37274, 37275No published answer located as at 3 November (due 26 October).Section 47 inquiries, child protection plans, looked-after children and foster/residential placement costs.
37761No published answer located as at 3 November (due 4 November).Children’s services guidance where an order is sought against a parent.
38967–38970Four questions unanswered at the 3 November check (due 2 November).Abuse of power; harm threshold; overseas conduct; NHS gender-service impacts.

Assessment: A ministerial assurance does not substitute for clear statutory wording. Conversely, the absence of an express exemption does not itself prove that ordinary parenting or professional conversations would satisfy every element of a criminal offence. The draft’s cumulative requirements and separate protection-order test must be analysed.

Impact Assessment scrutiny — justice, children’s social care and public expenditure

Government evidence What is costed? The Government’s draft final-stage Impact Assessment (IA CO2036) estimates approximately £59.7 million in ten-year costs for its preferred option (best estimate), comprising mainly £45.8 million public-sector familiarisation costs, £13.6 million private-sector costs and a small victim-support-service renewal cost. Its estimated £783 million ten-year monetised benefit is a modelled valuation of reductions in depression-related loss of quality of life, not a cash saving to the NHS or the Exchequer. The IA gives a low-to-high cost range of approximately £33.2 million–£103.3 million for the preferred option, excluding criminal justice costs. These figures are provisional.

Explicit assessment gap The Government states that impacts on the wider justice system are being assessed with the Ministry of Justice and will appear in a future IA. Consequently, the published preferred-option net benefit is not a fully costed whole-system estimate. The IA also envisages new safeguarding and enforcement activity by police, local authorities, social workers and teachers, but this does not establish the number of additional investigations, care cases or placements.

Questions that need quantified answers

  • Police and criminal justice: expected reports, investigations, charging decisions, prosecutions, defence and prosecution legal aid, hearings, appeals, prison and probation costs, and low/central/high scenarios.
  • Protection orders: anticipated applications, applicant bodies, evidential hearings, representation, enforcement, breach proceedings and potential effects on family disputes.
  • Children’s social care: additional referrals, section 17/section 47 assessments, child protection plans, court applications, children’s guardians, expert reports, foster placements and residential care. Distinguish cases already requiring intervention under existing law from any genuinely additional workload attributable to the draft.
  • Net public expenditure: distinguish QALY-based social benefits from cash-releasing savings; account for costs borne by different public bodies, including local authorities and family courts, and test sensitivity to the number of additional cases.

Parliamentary scrutiny — Rosie Duffield MP, questions tabled 22 October

Position verified at 3 November: 14 answered, eight unanswered The following official written questions directly test these gaps:

  • 37268 — when the Ministry of Justice’s wider justice-system impact assessment will be published; 37278 — Justice Secretary’s discussions about those impacts.
  • 37257 — local-authority workload and costs, including protection-order applications; 37270, 37271 and 37272 — capacity, consultation and representations from local authorities.
  • 37274 — possible changes to child-protection plans and looked-after children; 37275 — estimated additional foster-care and residential-placement costs.
  • 37254 and 37255 — proposed offence’s application to parental and teacher decisions concerning social transition; relevant to assumptions about referral volumes, but neither question establishes criminal liability.

Northern Ireland — separate jurisdiction, useful scrutiny comparator

Published 16 October The Northern Ireland Assembly’s Research and Information Service published a Review of Costs: Conversion Practices (Criminalisation) Bill, examining potential public-purse implications of Northern Ireland’s separate Bill. A companion Bill research paper addresses policy and comparative issues. Northern Ireland’s Bill was introduced on 30 June 2026 and is in Committee Stage. Its cost analysis cannot simply be transferred to the England and Wales draft: legislative tests, enforcement arrangements, baseline services and budgets must first be compared. The relevant lesson is the value of a separately itemised public-purse assessment.

Independent representations — distinguish claims from demonstrated impacts

18–19 October Family-law barrister Sarah Phillimore, in Battlefest 2026 — Conversion Practices Bill (18 October), argues that the draft’s potential effects on family investigations, care proceedings and foster or residential placements have not been adequately costed. This is her analysis and a warning about possible pathways, not a quantified forecast that the Bill will result in removals.

Stakeholder claim In public comments dated 19 October supplied to Protect and Teach, the Evidence-Based Social Work Alliance (EBSWA) argues that child-protection investigations and family proceedings could generate substantial local-authority and legal costs. EBSWA suggested that £700,000 could be incurred by a single authority in a complex case. That figure is an unverified illustrative claim, not a Government estimate or an established average case cost. The Alliance’s full Joint Committee submission has not yet been reviewed here; its contents should not be described as verified submitted evidence until the original is obtained.

Analytical safeguard: A report, referral, investigation, prosecution, care application and removal of a child are distinct stages, each with different legal thresholds. Neither an allegation of a conversion practice nor parental disagreement automatically produces a care order. Scrutiny should test the statutory routes, likely incidence, incremental costs and existing safeguards rather than assume outcomes.

Next checks Review Duffield’s answers as published (initial due dates 26–28 October); review the downloadable EBSWA submission in full and Phillimore’s earlier detailed briefing; read the Northern Ireland cost paper’s methodology in full; and check for a revised England and Wales IA before any final Bill is introduced.

Confirmed Reported / stakeholder Awaited Open question Protect and Teach work

Protect and Teach position: the draft should not proceed

Protect and Teach opposes the June 2026 Draft Conversion Practices Bill. Its published 769-page Policy Analysis Paper No. 1 concludes that the case for the proposed criminal and preventive regime has not been established. The organisation’s objections concern legal certainty, the evidential basis for necessity and causation, safeguards for children and family life, lawful therapy and expression, civil protection orders, proportionality and the availability of existing law.

Scope of the objection: Opposition to this particular draft is not a defence of abusive conduct. Existing safeguarding duties and criminal laws remain relevant. Our assessment is that serious harm must be addressed through lawful, clearly defined and evidence-supported measures without unnecessarily restricting legitimate professional practice or family relationships.

Joint Committee: positions on the June 2026 draft

Research checked: 23 October 2026; earlier member positions retained unless a new attributable statement is identified. This register records attributable comments on this draft (or notes where none was identified). It will be updated with public Committee evidence and members’ further contributions. There has been no substantive parliamentary vote on the June 2026 draft. Historic votes and other policy positions are in the separate expandable section below.

MemberPosition on this draft / extent of evidenceOfficial records
Alex Barros-Curtis MP
Labour · Chair
On 25 June supported swift legislation, said he had spoken extensively with the Minister, and rejected consent as legitimising abuse. This does not establish approval of every clause.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Olivia Bailey MP
Labour
Presented and defended the draft as Minister on 25 June; recognised the risk of a chilling effect while arguing that healthcare safeguards would protect legitimate practice.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Danny Beales MP
Labour
Welcomed the comprehensive and inclusive draft on 25 June and asked that the healthcare-professional exception not create a loophole.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Marie Goldman MP
Liberal Democrat
On 14 May 2026 called for urgent publication of a trans-inclusive conversion-practices Bill. This predates the June draft and does not establish approval of its individual clauses. No subsequent clause-specific statement identified.Individual voting record
Hansard, 14 May 2026
Naz Shah MP
Labour
No individual statement on the June 2026 draft identified in the sources reviewed. Her recorded support for an earlier 2024 Bill appears in the background section.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Sir Jeremy Wright KC MP MP
Conservative
No individual statement on the June 2026 draft identified in the sources reviewed.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Baroness Brown of Silvertown
Labour
On 1 July welcomed the legislation and sought protection against abuse without criminalising conversations about sexuality or gender identity.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Baroness Browning
Conservative
No individual statement on the June 2026 draft identified in the sources reviewed.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Lord Hope of Craighead
Crossbench
No individual statement on the June 2026 draft identified in the sources reviewed.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Lord Isaac
Labour
On 1 July welcomed the draft and stated his view that it addresses gaps in existing criminal law.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Baroness Prentis of Banbury KC
Conservative
No individual statement on the June 2026 draft identified in the sources reviewed.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record
Lord Scriven
Liberal Democrat
On 1 July welcomed legislation while calling for precise safeguards for parents, teachers, clinicians and therapists providing lawful, non-directive support.Individual voting record
Relevant parliamentary record

Evidence standard: A general statement about LGBT rights, an earlier Bill or a separate parliamentary division does not establish an individual position on every provision of the June 2026 draft. The register does not forecast votes or Committee conclusions. Official membership · Chair’s official career record.

Wider relevant parliamentary record

This expandable record contains selected earlier votes, statements, official roles and reported legal advice relevant to the issues under scrutiny. It does not treat such context as a position on the June 2026 draft, and it is not a political biography.

Expand: sourced earlier parliamentary positions and background (12 members)
  • Alex Barros-Curtis MP: 31 August 2026: signed EDM 240 seeking disapproval of the proposed EHRC services code. In a public statement of 31 July and ministerial letter dated 30 July, raised concerns over trans people’s access to services and identified stakeholder discussions including Stonewall. This concerns the EHRC code, not the conversion-practices draft.
  • Olivia Bailey MP: On 29 April 2026 discussed the proposed ban and abuse targeted by it; on 24 June 2026 defended the intended legislation and addressed religious and pastoral support. These statements predate the published June draft. In February 2025 Hansard, backed a trans-inclusive ban. On 14 April 2026, as Minister, said single-sex spaces were vital and should be protected.
  • Danny Beales MP: Signed EDM 240 (official signature record: 10 June 2026). In a public statement dated 12 June 2026, described his concerns about the EHRC services code. Secondary-source record: TheyWorkForYou (2 July 2025) lists him among MPs associated with a letter raising concerns about an earlier draft code; the original signed letter has not been independently authenticated.
  • Marie Goldman MP: On 14 May 2026 called for urgent publication of a trans-inclusive conversion-practices Bill; this predates publication of the draft and does not amount to approval of its individual clauses. On 1 June 2026 criticised the proposed EHRC code as unworkable and exclusionary, and signed EDM 240. Her 14 April 2026 Westminster Hall contribution addressed implications of the For Women Scotland judgment.
  • Naz Shah MP: Voted Aye by proxy at Second Reading of the distinct 2024 Conversion Practices (Prohibition) Bill (Division 86). She also raised transgender hate-crime protections in 2018 Committee questioning.
  • Sir Jeremy Wright KC MP MP: Former Attorney General. No recorded vote in the 1 March 2024 conversion-practices division. Voted Aye on the separate 23 June 2026 PATHWAYS motion; this was not a vote on conversion practices.
  • Baroness Brown of Silvertown: As Lyn Brown MP, voted Aye on the 2024 Conversion Practices (Prohibition) Bill. In December 2016 Hansard, called for assessment of an informed-consent model for transgender healthcare; this was a request to assess, not unconditional endorsement.
  • Baroness Browning: In May 2025 Lords Hansard, supported implementation of the For Women Scotland ruling and sex-based provision in NHS changing facilities.
  • Lord Hope of Craighead: In January 2023 Lords Hansard, addressed the legal and constitutional dispute over the section 35 order affecting Scotland’s Gender Recognition Reform Bill.
  • Lord Isaac: Chaired Stonewall (2003–2012), documented in a parliamentary CV; appointed EHRC Chair in 2016 (GOV.UK announcement). An August 2020 interview discussed women-only spaces and freedom of expression. These prior roles and remarks do not determine his views on individual clauses.
  • Baroness Prentis of Banbury KC: Reported legal advice in an official capacity, not a personal public policy statement: The Times (20 July 2023) reported that, when Attorney General, she advised ministers that a blanket prohibition on social transition in schools would be unlawful under equality law; see also its earlier reporting. The advice itself is confidential and its contents have not been independently authenticated. It must not be attributed as her personal position.
  • Lord Scriven: Supported progressing earlier trans-inclusive conversion-practices legislation in February 2024. Asked a written question on 2 June 2026 about the EHRC code and raised practical and proportionality concerns during the 3 June 2026 Lords debate. His direct July 2026 draft-Bill comments remain in the table above.

2024 division context: At the Second Reading division on 1 March 2024, 68 MPs voted Aye and 15 Noes were recorded, but the Question was not agreed to because fewer than 100 supported it. This concerned a different Bill, not the June 2026 draft. Official division.

Separate PATHWAYS record: On 23 June 2026, the opposition motion concerning PATHWAYS was a distinct parliamentary question. The division records No votes by Alex Barros-Curtis, Olivia Bailey and Danny Beales, and an Aye by Sir Jeremy Wright. An absence from the division is not an expression of opposition or support.

Method: EDM signatures are not votes. Reports of confidential advice are not authenticated private legal opinions or personal political statements. All other positions are attributed to the speaker and dated; no inference is made about how anyone will conduct scrutiny.

Government & Parliament

Official publications and parliamentary scrutiny milestones.

  • Confirmed

    Draft Bill published

    The Government published the Draft Conversion Practices Bill on 25 June 2026. It applies to England and Wales and proposes three principal measures: a criminal offence relating to abusive conversion practices; an offence concerning encouraging or assisting such practices abroad; and Conversion Practice Protection Orders.

    25 Jun 2026 · GOV.UK draft Bill page

  • Confirmed

    Impact Assessment published

    The draft final-stage Impact Assessment says costs and benefits remain provisional during pre-legislative scrutiny and may be revised before any final Bill is introduced. It also states that impacts on the wider justice system are being assessed with the Ministry of Justice for inclusion in future iterations.

    GOV.UK Impact Assessment

  • Confirmed

    Equality Impact Assessment published

    The Equality Impact Assessment describes important limitations in the evidence base, including limited representative UK data, methodological variation and limitations in drawing causal conclusions from the available literature.

    GOV.UK Equality Impact Assessment

  • Confirmed

    Explanatory Notes published

    The Government’s Explanatory Notes explain the intended operation of the draft clauses but do not form part of the Bill and have not been endorsed by Parliament.

    GOV.UK Explanatory Notes

  • Confirmed

    Joint Committee appointed

    A 12-member Joint Committee of six MPs and six members of the House of Lords was appointed in September 2026 to scrutinise the draft Bill. The appointment announcement was published on 18 September 2026.

    18 Sep 2026 · UK Parliament

  • Confirmed

    Committee reporting deadline

    The Joint Committee is required to report by 22 January 2027.

    UK Parliament

  • Confirmed

    Membership update — Naz Shah MP

    The current membership and Parliament’s 18 September appointment announcement both include Naz Shah MP. The verified register below supersedes differing early commentary.

    Checked 19 Oct 2026 · Current Committee membership

  • Chair identified

    Alex Barros-Curtis MP appointed Chair

    The official parliamentary career record identifies the Labour MP for Cardiff West as Chair from 12 October 2026 (member since 10 September 2026). His recorded comments and voting history appear in the Committee-member register.

    Current membership · Commons voting record

  • Confirmed

    Private Committee meeting diary

    Parliament lists private Joint Committee meetings for Monday 12 October 2026, 4:00–6:00 pm, and Thursday 15 October 2026, 12:00–1:30 pm. Both were listed for Room 4, Palace of Westminster. No public oral-evidence session is specified.

    12 and 15 Oct 2026 · UK Parliament Committee page

  • Listed by Parliament

    Private Committee meeting — 19 October

    Parliament’s Committee homepage lists a private meeting on Monday 19 October 2026 at 4pm, Room 4, Palace of Westminster, scheduled to end at 6pm. This is a private meeting, not a public evidence session; no outcome is inferred.

    Official upcoming events

  • Listed by Parliament

    Further private meetings — 22 and 26 October

    Parliament lists a private meeting for Thursday 22 October, 12–1:30 pm, Room 4, and another for Monday 26 October, 4–6 pm, Room 2, Palace of Westminster. These are scheduled private meetings, not public hearings or published decisions.

  • Witnesses announced

    First public oral-evidence session — 29 October

    Parliament’s event record lists an oral-evidence session for Thursday 29 October 2026, 12–3 pm. The six witnesses and Room 2 are confirmed on the official parliamentary meeting page. A session being listed does not establish what evidence will be heard.

  • Confirmed — 27 October update

    Written evidence open; oral-evidence witnesses named

    Parliament has published the formal written-evidence call, closing 16 November 2026, and named the six witnesses for the scheduled 29 October oral-evidence hearing. The hearing took place on 29 October; both uncorrected transcripts were published on 2 November. See the prominent evidence-call box and detailed entries above.

    Follow the Committee

Under scrutiny / unresolved

Questions likely to matter during pre-legislative scrutiny.

  • Open question

    What conduct fills the claimed legal gap?

    What serious conduct targeted by the draft Bill is currently lawful, how often does it occur, and why are existing criminal, civil, safeguarding and professional mechanisms insufficient?

  • Open question

    How certain are the key definitions?

    How will courts apply concepts such as “conversion practice”, “abusive” conduct, intention, serious harm, alarm or distress, and the boundaries between prohibited conduct and lawful conversation, advice, therapy, parenting or pastoral support?

  • Open question

    What does the prevalence evidence establish?

    The Government acknowledges substantial limitations in the evidence base. Scrutiny will need to distinguish reported experiences from conduct satisfying every element of the proposed criminal offence.

  • Open question

    What evidence establishes causation?

    The Government’s Equality Impact Assessment identifies limitations in establishing causal relationships from the available evidence. Parliament will need to consider what conclusions can safely be drawn from correlational, retrospective and self-reported evidence.

  • Open question

    Parents, therapists and safeguarding

    How will the framework protect legitimate exploratory conversations, professional judgement and proportionate safeguarding while still identifying genuinely abusive conduct?

    Sex Matters’ 7 October 2026 article, When parents become suspects, raises stakeholder concerns about refusals involving clothing, names and related parental decisions; the legal elements of the offence would still have to be established.

  • Open question

    Healthcare safeguard and professional standards

    Conduct carried out in the course of providing healthcare is excluded from the definition of a conversion practice unless the provider acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position. Scrutiny will need to examine how sufficiently certain and predictable that threshold is in practice, including how relevant professional standards would be identified and applied.

  • Open question

    Chilling effects and access to therapy

    Stakeholders including mental-health professionals interviewed by Sex Matters have raised concerns that fear of complaints, investigations or legal proceedings could affect willingness to work with gender-distressed or trans-identifying clients. Scrutiny will need to test whether such effects are likely, their possible scale, and whether the draft safeguards adequately address them.

  • Open question

    Children and family relationships

    The draft offence does not contain a general exemption for parents or family members. Scrutiny will need to examine how the offence and protection-order regime would operate in ordinary family relationships, particularly where parents are making safeguarding, welfare or healthcare decisions concerning children.

  • Open question

    Sexual orientation and transgender identity

    The draft Bill applies its conversion-practice framework to both sexual orientation and transgender identity. Scrutiny will need to examine whether the evidence base, concepts, potential harms and appropriate safeguards are sufficiently comparable to justify their treatment within the same legislative framework.

  • Open question

    Conversion Practice Protection Orders

    What evidential threshold, procedural safeguards and limits will apply to civil protection orders, particularly where allegations concern intention, identity, psychological effects, private conversations or family relationships?

  • Open question

    Human-rights and proportionality questions

    How will the final scheme address legal certainty, freedom of expression, freedom of thought, conscience and religion, private and family life, and proportionality?

  • Open question

    Monitoring effectiveness

    What outcomes will demonstrate that legislation reduced serious harm rather than merely increasing reports, referrals, investigations, guidance or training activity? What baseline will be used and how will unintended consequences be identified?

  • Awaited

    Joint Committee evidence

    A public call for written evidence, submission deadline, names of witnesses for the listed 29 October hearing, oral-evidence transcripts and any specialist-adviser material are awaited. Protect and Teach will update this tracker as Parliament publishes substantive material.

  • Awaited

    Committee report and Government response

    The Joint Committee must report by 22 January 2027. The Government will then decide how to respond and whether to introduce legislation in revised form.

  • New stakeholder issue

    Children affected by parental transition; disclosures and family safeguarding

    Transgender Trend and Children of Transitioners have raised concerns that the draft may inadequately address children’s experiences of abuse or discourage children and non-transitioning parents from seeking help. These are stakeholder claims requiring scrutiny, not established automatic consequences of the Bill. The draft does not immunise anyone from existing child-protection or domestic-abuse law, and it does not criminalise merely asking for help without the relevant statutory elements.

    Specific questions: how will complaints, protection-order applications and allegations of intention be handled in contested family cases? What protection exists for child disclosures, safeguarding referrals, parents and independent therapy?

    Transgender Trend post · Children of Transitioners post · Background account

Protect and Teach work

Protect and Teach publications, submissions and parliamentary-facing material.

  • Published 25 October 2026

    Who Is Driving Conversion Practices Bans?

    Research on the WHO, UN, Council of Europe, EU and Australian approaches, including the Government’s documented international legislative comparisons and ten supplementary scrutiny questions.

    Read the published article · Summary and primary sources

  • Published

    Policy Analysis Paper No. 1

    Draft Conversion Practices Bill (England and Wales): An Evidence Review and Policy Analysis — a 769-page review of the evidence base, legal framework, safeguarding implications, Government assessments and international comparisons.

    September 2026 · Read the publication page

  • Published

    8-page Policy Evidence Briefing

    A shorter briefing for parliamentarians, professionals, journalists and the public, distilling the principal findings and nine questions for scrutiny.

    Access from the publication page

  • Published

    Template letter for MPs

    An editable public template enabling constituents to ask MPs to examine the evidential basis for the draft Bill and select specific scrutiny questions.

    Access from the publication page

  • Position

    Protect and Teach conclusion

    Protect and Teach’s published analysis concludes that the evidential case for this particular criminal and preventive regime has not been established and that the draft Bill should not proceed.

    Read the full reasoning

  • Action

    Support for open letter

    Protect and Teach supported an open letter coordinated by LGB Alliance opposing the draft Bill and raising concerns about parents, children and professionals.

    25 August 2026 · Protect and Teach article

  • Published · 19 October 2026

    A Minister’s Assurance Is Not a Statutory Safeguard

    Protect and Teach’s response to Bridget Phillipson’s 18 October article, comparing the Minister’s assurances with the actual wording of the draft Bill. The article examines parents, the definition of abuse, the alternative clause 2 thresholds, preventative orders and the conditional healthcare exclusion. It maintains the recommendation to withdraw the draft.

    Read Protect and Teach’s response

  • Awaited

    Joint Committee submission / evidence

    Protect and Teach intends to review any call for evidence and will record here any submission, published evidence or parliamentary engagement as the Joint Committee’s scrutiny develops.

  • Awaited

    Response to Committee report

    Protect and Teach will review the Joint Committee’s conclusions and any subsequent Government response against the evidence and issues identified in Policy Analysis Paper No. 1.

25 October 2026 — Protect and Teach: international policy and the draft Bill

Published research Who Is Driving Conversion Practices Bans? examines the WHO, United Nations, Council of Europe, European Commission, Australia and the UK’s Draft Conversion Practices Bill. It links to the existing 769-page policy analysis and eight-page briefing.

WHO: The WHO’s 2025 mental-health guidance, Module 2, page 66, explicitly recommends policies banning conversion therapy and forced practices intended to change sexual orientation. It does not prescribe the UK’s particular criminal offence. WHO Module 2.

European and UN developments: Council of Europe Resolution 2643 (2026) urges national prohibitions, criminal sanctions and conversion therapy protection orders. The European Commission’s 2026 response plans a Recommendation encouraging national bans in 2027. The UN Independent Expert’s 2020 report (A/HRC/44/53) called for a global prohibition. These instruments differ in legal authority and do not compel UK enactment of this draft.

Documented international comparison: Section EB 1.5 of the Government’s June 2026 Impact Assessment records review of national and selected regional prohibitions, including Australian legislation. It states that all known national legislative bans include transgender identity or gender identity alongside sexual orientation and describes the UK approach as largely in line with peer nations, with exceptions. This establishes policy comparison, not proof that a specific clause was copied or mandated internationally.

Victorian review: The Victorian Law Reform Commission’s statutory review, initiated in February 2026, required a report to the Attorney-General by 28 August. The Commission reports delivery but, as at this update, public release is not established. Its terms of reference expressly ask why no criminal offences have been prosecuted under the Act. No prosecutions alone do not prove success or failure.

Scrutiny: The new article identifies ten additional international-policy questions, supplementing rather than replacing the nine questions in the established Protect and Teach briefing. International endorsement does not itself establish the necessity, legal precision or proportionality of a particular UK regime.

24–25 October 2026 — Stakeholder developments and related safeguarding context

24 October — Transgender Trend In commentary reported in the 25 October stakeholder update, Transgender Trend argues that the Bill could have the opposite of its stated effect, by encouraging police, schools and social workers to scrutinise parents who decline to facilitate social transition. This is the organisation’s interpretation, not a proven legal consequence. The offence and protection-order provisions have their own statutory criteria, and ordinary disagreement is not automatically criminalised. The specific original post URL remains to be verified; Transgender Trend’s account.

Related clinical safeguarding — WellBN, Brighton An NHS Surrey and Sussex ICB independent patient-safety investigation concluded that prescribing at WellBN fell well below acceptable standards and that potential harm was caused to 78 children and young people within its scope. This does not mean that physical injury was individually proved in all 78 cases. The findings concern specialist oversight, clinical competence, assessment, consent and prescribing, rather than the terms of the Draft Conversion Practices Bill.

Responses requiring original-source verification Social-media reports attribute calls for further independent inquiry and regulatory action to Hilary Cass, and criticism of NHS England to Dr Sarah Redvers. Precise wording, original posts and any actual GMC decision should be verified before they are treated as confirmed institutional or regulatory developments. No regulator suspension is established by this entry.

Cross-tracker boundary: Substantive WellBN clinical and regulatory developments belong primarily in NHS/children’s safeguarding research. The reported Scottish Mail on Sunday allegation concerning Dr Beth Upton, shared by For Women Scotland on 25 October, concerns the separate NHS Fife/Sandie Peggie matter and should not be imported as a finding on this Bill without original reporting and verification.

24 October 2026 — Further stakeholder material identified

Sex Matters — further public commentary Sex Matters has argued that existing offences already address abusive conduct and that the draft could affect lawful conversations and ordinary parental decisions. These are its legal and policy arguments, not findings of a court or the Joint Committee. Compare the claims with the Government’s stated rationale in its impact assessment, the offence’s statutory elements and the existing-law analysis. Its 20 October letter is already recorded elsewhere on this page.

Battle of Ideas — recording available The full discussion Conversion Practices Bill: criminalising parents, teachers and priests?, featuring Jan Macvarish, Lucy Beney and Helen Joyce, is available as a recorded debate. Transgender Trend commended the discussion and For Women Scotland circulated it. Panel contributions are stakeholder opinion, not formal parliamentary evidence.

Further material for source verification Transgender Trend has circulated a clip attributed to Lord Frost concerning medical interventions for children and shared BBC reporting concerning Dr Sarah Redvers and WellBN. The original parliamentary context, BBC report and tribunal materials should be checked before treating these as substantive legal or regulatory developments. The latter reporting is not itself an amendment to this draft Bill.

Cross-tracker boundary: Sex Matters’ criticism of the BMA’s use of “gender history” belongs primarily in the Health Bill/NHS single-sex provision research, rather than being presented as a conversion-practices legislative development.

Stakeholder watch — 24 October 2026

Stakeholder report Transgender Trend reported that a Battle of Ideas discussion about the draft Bill attracted a large audience and expressed concern about possible effects on safeguarding, family relationships and free expression. This is the organisation’s account of a public event, not a representative audience survey, Committee evidence or parliamentary finding. Original stakeholder post.

Stakeholder advocacy LGB Alliance has continued publishing video testimonies opposing the draft Bill. These may inform scrutiny of personal experiences and predicted impacts, but do not themselves establish the legal consequences of the proposed clauses. LGB Alliance account. Its separate Battle of Ideas panel on the PATHWAYS trial concerns a different policy issue.

20 October stakeholder developments Sex Matters’ letter requests explicit protection for parents; Gay Men’s Network’s response challenges the Minister’s article, and LGB Alliance’s further testimony video records an individual account. These are advocacy and testimony, not official Committee evidence or findings.

22 October — LGB Alliance The organisation renewed promotion of its open letter, using the words “LGB people are not a prop for this Bill” and arguing that the draft could harm children who later identify as LGB and inhibit honest discussion. This is an attributed campaign claim, not an established legal outcome. LGB Alliance’s public account (specific post URL awaiting confirmation).

22 October — Transgender Trend The organisation shared the LGB Alliance message and argued that the draft could expose a parent reassuring a teenage daughter about being lesbian to criminal liability, and inhibit discussion of adolescent sexuality and gender identity. The hypothetical requires testing against the offence’s intention, abusive-conduct and consequence requirements; reassurance alone is not established to constitute an offence. Transgender Trend’s public account (specific post URL awaiting confirmation).

EBSWA — published evidence The Evidence-Based Social Work Alliance has published a submission download on its own website, addressing child safeguarding, parental responsibility and professional judgement. This confirms an organisation-published document, not that the Joint Committee has formally received or published it.

Evidence status: Stakeholder statements are not findings of the Joint Committee. EBSWA publishes a submission on its own website, but formal Committee receipt or publication has not been verified. The draft Bill and its published assessments remain the primary sources for the proposed law.

Stakeholder publications and evidence register

Two distinct published positions are recorded below: organisations raising objections to the draft Bill, and organisations supporting its introduction or calling for stronger protections. Each entry retains its publication date, a brief description and an original source link. Inclusion does not imply endorsement. Publication counts are not counts of independent studies. Research, legal analysis, policy briefings and campaigning statements are distinguished. The Government’s draft Bill and assessments remain the primary sources for what the proposals contain.

Organisations opposing or raising substantial objections

Nine organisations or stakeholder groups are included below. Counts distinguish longer publications from letters, testimonies and social-media statements; entries are not independent research studies. Expand each organisation for dated links. The precise positions and recommendations may differ. The 3 November research and stakeholder supplement above updates these historical entries without removing earlier sources.

Sex Matters 6 publications + 1 letter + 1 commentary + 3 reported items (11 entries)

Publishes research, legal analysis and policy commentary objecting to the draft legislation. Individual publications are preserved below.

  • Reported 27 October 2026 · New briefing (direct publication link pending verification)
    Who may be at risk of criminalisation?

    Sex Matters is reported to have published a further briefing examining possible criminalisation risks. This is a stakeholder legal assessment, not an established interpretation by a court. Sex Matters website; the precise briefing URL and publication date remain to be checked.

  • Reported 27 October 2026 · Submission guidance (direct publication link pending verification)
    Guide to giving evidence to the Joint Committee

    Sex Matters has reportedly published guidance for potential respondents. The official Committee instructions and 16 November deadline take precedence. Official call for evidence.

  • Reported 27 October 2026 · Video commentary (direct video link pending verification)
    Marcus and Susan Evans — Tavistock-related concerns

    Sex Matters reportedly shared a video featuring Marcus and Susan Evans discussing potential effects on children and families. Their views are stakeholder commentary, not a Committee finding. Sex Matters account; the individual video link remains to be verified.

  • 23 October 2026 · Public commentary reported; exact original post to verify
    Sex Matters — further commentary on existing law and parental conversations

    Argues that existing offences address abusive conduct and that the proposed offence could affect lawful conversations and parental decisions. This is an attributed interpretation; a direct post URL and publication date require verification.

  • 20 October 2026 · Letter / public statement
    Letter to Bridget Phillipson requesting express parental safeguards

    Sex Matters says ministerial assurances do not provide an express parental protection in the draft and requests that the proposed legislation be changed. This is an attributed stakeholder interpretation, not a court ruling.

  • 12 October 2026 · Policy briefing
    Briefing on the Conversion Practices Bill

    Parliamentary briefing summarising eight concerns about the draft legislation, including family life, protection orders, therapeutic practice, safeguarding, legal certainty and freedom of expression. This is a policy briefing drawing on earlier analysis, rather than a separate independent empirical study.

  • 12 October 2026 · Commentary
    Scrutiny starts on the draft Conversion Practices Bill

    Explains the beginning of parliamentary pre-legislative scrutiny and presents Sex Matters’ principal objections.

  • 7 October 2026 · Analysis
    When parents become suspects

    Examines how parental decisions could, in the organisation’s view, give rise to allegations or investigations. The scenarios are stakeholder interpretations of potential effects; they must be distinguished from the statutory elements required to establish a criminal offence.

  • 1 October 2026 · Qualitative research
    Criminalising conversations — Matilda Gosling

    Qualitative report based on interviews with 30 mental-health professionals, including practitioners experienced in work with gender-distressed or trans-identifying clients. The findings concern the experiences and reported intentions of the interviewees. They are not representative estimates of the UK mental-health workforce.

  • 1 July 2026 · Evidence critique
    Conversion therapy: still not illegal — or still not happening?

    Critiques elements of the reported prevalence evidence, helpline activity and arguments about the necessity of creating a new criminal offence.

  • 25 June 2026 · Legal and policy briefing
    Draft Conversion Practices Bill — initial briefing

    Initial response to the Government’s published draft, focusing on its proposed legal provisions and implications.

Our Duty 1 publication (1 entry)

Parent-focused material opposing the draft legislation.

  • September 2026 · Circulated 12 October 2026 · Parent guide
    Tell them the truth — A Parent’s Briefing

    Four-image briefing discussing the absence of a general parental exemption, concerns about family decision-making, protection orders, allegations and possible safeguarding consequences.

    The briefing’s predicted consequences should be treated as advocacy claims rather than established legal outcomes. Protect and Teach has already examined these legal questions in its Policy Analysis Paper No. 1, particularly Sections 7.8 and 7.11.

Genspect 1 publication (1 entry)

Published an analysis critical of the evidence base relied upon in support of the draft.

Gay Men’s Network 1 legal analysis + 1 letter (2 entries)

Published detailed legal analysis of criminal-law, human-rights and family-law implications.

Transgender Trend 1 analysis + 7 statements/shares (8 entries)

Questions the research and evidence used to justify the draft legislation.

  • 24 October 2026 · Stakeholder commentary reported 25 October; direct post to verify
    Position concerning parental refusal of social transition

    Transgender Trend argues that the proposed regime may expose parental decisions to additional scrutiny by schools, social workers and police. This is attributed commentary, not a proven consequence of the Bill; original individual post URL not independently established.

  • 23 October 2026 · Shared recorded debate; original repost link to verify
    Battle of Ideas — Conversion Practices Bill: criminalising parents, teachers and priests?

    Transgender Trend recommended the debate featuring Jan Macvarish, Lucy Beney and Helen Joyce. Link goes to the recording, not the unverified repost.

  • 23 October 2026 · Shared parliamentary clip; direct post to verify
    Lord Frost clip circulated by CforWomenUK

    Clip attributed to Lord Frost discussing medical interventions for children. Full parliamentary context and the precise original post have not been verified.

  • 23 October 2026 · Shared BBC reporting; original report to verify
    BBC coverage concerning Dr Sarah Redvers and WellBN

    Transgender Trend circulated reporting about employment tribunal proceedings and WellBN in Brighton. The original report and tribunal decision require checking; this is contextual healthcare material rather than a change to the draft Bill.

  • 22 October 2026 · Campaign commentary (reported)
    Shared LGB Alliance’s renewed open-letter campaign

    Argued that the draft could affect parental reassurance about same-sex attraction and discussions about adolescent sexuality and gender identity. This is a stakeholder interpretation, not a confirmed criminal-law outcome; direct post link awaiting verification.

  • 18 October 2026 · Public commentary
    Response to Bridget Phillipson’s article

    Criticises the Government’s approach and raises concerns about the application of the proposed framework to children identifying as the opposite sex.

  • 7 July 2026 · Evidence critique
    Conversion Practices Bill — evidence analysis

    Examines evidence cited in support of the proposals, with particular emphasis on parents and gender-distressed children.

  • 13 October 2026 · Social-media statement (date of monitoring)
    Concerns about parental abuse and asymmetrical safeguarding

    Argues that the Bill does not sufficiently consider abuse against a child by a parent who has a transgender identity. The claimed gap is attributed to the organisation; existing child-abuse law remains in force.

Children of Transitioners 1 statement + 1 contextual article (2 entries)

Personal and family-experience organisation raising concerns about children’s emotional welfare when a parent transitions.

  • 13 October 2026 · Public statement (date monitored)
    Concerns about children and non-transitioning parents seeking help

    Claims the draft could expose children and mothers to allegations or deter disclosures. Those predicted consequences are not established legal outcomes and require examination against the actual offence and protection-order provisions.

  • Earlier published account · Background, not new October research
    Not Shutting Up

    Contextual account of family experiences; not an empirical prevalence study or a clause-by-clause assessment of the 2026 draft.

LGB Alliance 1 open letter + 4 updates (5 entries)

Opposes combining sexual-orientation and transgender-identity provisions within this legislative framework.

  • 28 October 2026 · APPG parliamentary engagement / stakeholder statement
    Kate Barker-Mawjee reports speaking at a Portcullis House APPG meeting

    The LGB Alliance CEO said she attended an All-Party Parliamentary Group meeting to discuss the potential impact of the proposed legislation on young lesbians. LGB Alliance described young lesbians as particularly at risk and mentioned Rosie Duffield MP. These are attributed stakeholder positions, not findings of the Joint Committee; the exact APPG name has not been established.

  • 22 October 2026 · Renewed open-letter appeal (reported)
    Renewed campaign and concerns about LGB young people

    Stated “LGB people are not a prop for this Bill” and argued that children who may grow up LGB could be harmed by restrictions on open discussion. Campaign interpretation; direct post link awaiting verification.

  • 20 October 2026 · Personal testimony video
    Charlotte’s testimony and the organisation’s open-letter campaign

    Individual testimony shared by LGB Alliance in support of its opposition to the draft; it does not establish prevalence or statutory interpretation.

  • 20 October 2026 · Social-media endorsement
    LGB Alliance shares Gay Men’s Network’s letter

    Endorses and circulates Gay Men’s Network’s response to the Minister. This is not a separate independent legal report.

  • August 2026 · Open letter / campaign
    Open letter coordinated by LGB Alliance

    Open letter opposing the draft and raising concerns about the consequences for parents, children and professionals. Protect and Teach recorded its support on 25 August 2026.

Evidence-Based Social Work Alliance (EBSWA) 1 published submission + 1 reported commentary (2 entries)

Social-work group raising concerns about statutory child-protection duties, family relationships and professional judgement. Publication on the group’s website does not establish receipt by Parliament.

  • September 2026 · Organisation-published submission (page dated 28 September)
    Why the Draft Conversion Practices Bill Must Not Be Passed — submission download

    The group’s published summary addresses safeguarding, parental responsibility and professional judgement. The linked downloadable submission requires full document-level review before any detailed numerical claims are attributed to it.

  • 19 October 2026 · Public social-media comments supplied to Protect and Teach

    Raised concerns about possible local-authority, family-court and placement costs, including an illustrative £700,000 claim. No underlying cost model has yet been independently validated.

CARE 1 publication (1 entry)

Raises concerns about legal necessity, definitions, family relationships and religious freedom.

Organisations supporting the draft or seeking stronger legislation

Three organisations identified at this stage. Supporting a ban in principle does not necessarily mean endorsing every provision of the current draft. The publications below are attributed to their authors and remain subject to the same evidential scrutiny. The 3 November research and stakeholder supplement above updates these historical entries without removing earlier sources.

Stonewall 1 publication (1 entry)

Welcomes legislation and argues that protections should be effective and inclusive.

Galop 2 publications (2 entries)

Supports legislation and reports frontline experience assisting clients who describe conversion practices.

  • June 2026 · Public statement / service case-series
    Conversion Practices Bill published after years of campaigning

    Welcomes the draft and discusses the organisation’s experience supporting people reporting conversion practices.

    Galop has also reported analysis of 195 service cases from 2022 to 2025. These are cases encountered through a specialist support service. They can provide information about reported experiences and service needs but are not a representative survey of national prevalence.

  • 20 October 2026 · Parliamentary scrutiny statement
    Scrutiny Begins on the draft Conversion Practices Bill

    Explains the Joint Committee process, supports an inclusive prohibition and calls for changes to strengthen the proposed regime. Cites frontline service evidence and Government survey figures; these sources have different populations and should not be conflated.

Consortium 1 publication (1 entry)

Welcomes publication and calls for stronger final protections.

Further research: A distinct, publicly available Bayswater Support Group submission addressing this 2026 draft has not yet been verified. Bayswater’s involvement in separate PATHWAYS litigation should not be recorded here as evidence concerning this Bill. Further relevant stakeholder publications, professional-body responses and formal Joint Committee submissions will be added individually when identified and verified.

Core sources

  1. Office for Equality and Opportunity, Draft Conversion Practices Bill , published 25 June 2026, updated 1 September 2026.
  2. Office for Equality and Opportunity, Draft final-stage Impact Assessment .
  3. Office for Equality and Opportunity, Draft Equality Impact Assessment .
  4. Office for Equality and Opportunity, Explanatory Notes .
  5. UK Parliament, Draft Conversion Practices Bill Joint Committee .
  6. UK Parliament, Joint Committee appointed , 18 September 2026.
  7. UK Parliament, Current Joint Committee membership , checked 13 October 2026.
  8. UK Parliament, Private Committee meeting — 12 October 2026 .
  9. UK Parliament, Private Committee meeting — 15 October 2026 .
  10. Protect and Teach CIC, Why the Evidence Does Not Support the Draft Conversion Practices Bill , September 2026.
  11. Matilda Gosling for Sex Matters, Criminalising conversations , 1 October 2026.
  12. Sex Matters, When parents become suspects , 7 October 2026.
  13. Sex Matters, Briefing on the Conversion Practices Bill , 12 October 2026.
  14. Our Duty, Tell them the truth — A Parent’s Briefing , circulated 12 October 2026.
  15. Genspect, Peter Jenkins’ evidence critique , 8 October 2026.
  16. Gay Men’s Network, Legal response to the draft Bill (PDF) , 2026.
  17. Transgender Trend, Evidence analysis , 7 July 2026.
  18. CARE, Commentary on the draft Bill , 25 June 2026.
  19. Stonewall, Statement on the draft Bill , 25 June 2026.
  20. Galop, Draft Bill response , June 2026.
  21. Consortium, Statement on the draft Bill , 25 June 2026.
  22. Hansard, Commons statement of 25 June 2026.
  23. Hansard, Lords discussion of 1 July 2026.
  24. Commons PATHWAYS motion division, 23 June 2026.
  25. Transgender Trend statement, October 2026.
  26. Children of Transitioners statement, October 2026.
  27. Joint Committee private meeting listing, 22 October 2026.
  28. Joint Committee private meeting listing, 26 October 2026.
  29. Joint Committee oral-evidence event listing, 29 October 2026.
  30. Bridget Phillipson, The Independent, 18 October 2026.
  31. Protect and Teach, A Minister’s Assurance Is Not a Statutory Safeguard, 19 October 2026.

Primary-source verification register — added 3 November

Draft Bill text · Explanatory Notes · Economic impact assessment · Equality impact assessment · 29 October transcript, panel 1 · 29 October transcript, panel 2 · 2 November hearing record · Formal minutes · Correspondence register · Stonewall 2026 survey.

Checked: 3 November 2026. Parliamentary questions and hearing transcripts may be updated subsequently. The entries above are a dated snapshot, not a claim that every unanswered question remains unanswered indefinitely.