Protect and Teach CIC · Live Tracker

Health Bill 2026–27

Puberty blockers, PATHWAYS and single-sex NHS provision

Tracking the Health Bill through the House of Lords, with particular attention to safeguarding children, the PATHWAYS puberty-suppression trial, and single-sex NHS facilities for patients and staff.

Last substantive update: 20 November 2026  |  Parliamentary record checked: 20 November 2026

What’s new — 20 November 2026

  • Five Lords Committee sittings completed. The fifth took place on 17 November, following sittings on 28 October and 3, 9 and 11 November. Official minutes.
  • Baroness Cass and children’s healthcare: she moved Amendment 66, seeking duties on integrated care boards concerning children’s waiting times. Her wider contributions addressed children’s health, medical records and gender-related clinical standards. 17 November Hansard.
  • Clinical standards and the Conversion Practices Bill: Cass discussed proposed Amendment 279QP, addressing the treatment and assessment of gender-related distress in children. This is a Health Bill amendment proposal referencing a separate draft Bill, not an amendment to that draft Bill. Read the contribution.
  • Recorded Committee decisions: Amendments 103 and 104 were agreed on 17 November. This does not mean the Health Bill has completed its Lords stages. Minutes.
  • Single-sex NHS provisions: proposed Amendments 166, 260, 261 and 264 remain on the watch list; no agreement to these proposals is established by the 17 November proceedings reviewed. Official amendment register.

What’s next — dates and decisions to watch

  • Monday 23 November: next scheduled Lords Committee sitting, with debate expected on medical-malpractice reporting, pharmacy provision, hospice medicines and primary-care investment. Parliament’s preview.
  • Wednesday 25 November and Tuesday 8 December: further Committee sittings currently scheduled, subject to change.
  • Single-sex facilities and intimate care: check whether Amendments 166, 260, 261 and 264 are reached, debated, withdrawn, amended or agreed. Grouping is not approval.
  • PATHWAYS: check King’s College London’s trial information, the published protocol, recruitment notices, regulatory updates and any response to Baroness Deech’s questions. Trial approval is not evidence of recruitment.
  • Healthwatch and the single patient record: check whether the Government’s Healthwatch reversal is reflected in formal amendments, and follow confidentiality, access and audit safeguards.
  • Later stages: Lords Report, Third Reading and any Commons consideration of Lords amendments remain ahead. The Bill is not law.

Current parliamentary position — 20 November

Health Bill 2026–27, HL Bill 52: Commons stages are complete; the House of Lords has completed Second Reading and held five Committee sittings. Further Committee days are scheduled. No Royal Assent or commencement has occurred.

Committee chronology: 28 October; 3, 9, 11 and 17 November (completed). Next listed: 23 November, 25 November and 8 December (scheduled).

Important distinction: the Commons rejected NC142 and NC143 on 8 September. Later Lords proposals revisit some related subjects but are not the same amendments and must be assessed individually. Official stages · Official documents.

17 November — children’s health and clinical standards

Baroness Cass: Amendment 66 and wider children’s healthcare

Baroness Cass moved Amendment 66 concerning waiting-time duties for children’s services commissioned by integrated care boards. Her argument was that a health-system restructuring must account explicitly for children’s developmental needs, including the consequences of delayed treatment. This is a proposal and parliamentary contribution, not an enacted duty.

Gender-related clinical practice: in her contribution on Amendment 279QP, Cass discussed the need for appropriate standards for the assessment and treatment of children experiencing gender-related distress. She raised concerns about uncertainty for clinicians, and explicitly distinguished abusive conversion practices from legitimate clinical work. The amendment’s progress and exact text should be checked before stating any outcome.

Connection to Protect and Teach’s other work: Our analysis of five Conversion Practices Bill hearings addresses a related question about the evidence for new criminal law. The draft Conversion Practices Bill is a separate parliamentary inquiry, not a clause of the Health Bill.

Official record: 17 November Lords Hansard (PDF) · Minutes and amendment decisions.

Priority amendments — live status watch

AmendmentIssuePosition at this check
66 — Baroness CassChildren’s waiting times and ICB dutiesMoved and debated on 17 November; no agreement claimed here
103, 104Committee amendments considered on 17 NovemberAgreed in official minutes; Committee stage continues
166 — Baroness CashRecording sex in health informationProposal; outcome not established in proceedings checked
260, 261 — Baroness CashSingle-sex NHS provision; requests for same-sex intimate careProposals; no agreement established
264 — Baroness CoffeyHospital sleeping accommodation by sexProposal; no agreement established
279QP — Baroness CassClinical standards for gender-related distress in childrenDiscussed on 17 November; verify formal disposition
PATHWAYS-related proposalsTrial safeguards, consent and childrenCheck current wording, grouping and outcome individually

Method: “Proposed” and “discussed” are not synonyms for “agreed”. Historical amendment descriptions below are retained with their original dates. Check the live parliamentary amendment register.

Historical research retained: The sections below preserve the full earlier tracker, including the 14 November parliamentary assessment, both Protect and Teach submissions, PATHWAYS research and legal background, single-sex NHS proposals, division results and source links. Dates and “next sitting” statements within these earlier entries describe the position at that time; use the current summary above for today’s procedural status.
14 November 2026 — verified parliamentary catch-up

Health Bill: four Committee sittings completed; fifth scheduled for 17 November

Procedural position: The House of Lords considered the Health Bill in Committee on 28 October, 3 November, 9 November and 11 November. The fourth sitting proceeded through Clause 15. These proceedings must be distinguished from proposed new clauses and amendments that have not been reached or agreed.

11 November — day four: Peers considered proposals concerning specialised commissioning for children and young people, workplace health support, access to dentistry and the provision of NHS services by public bodies. The official minutes record that consideration resumed at Amendment 53 and concluded after Clause 15 was agreed. No adoption of the single-sex NHS amendments or PATHWAYS-specific proposals is established by that sitting.

12 November — additional scrutiny time agreed: The Lords agreed a Business of the House motion disapplying the usual order of business on 17 and 25 November so that Health Bill Committee proceedings may begin before oral questions. This is a procedural change, not an amendment to the Bill.

Next sitting — Tuesday 17 November at 11 am: The fifth Committee sitting is scheduled to examine further proposals, including provisions on adult gender services, service specifications, data and reporting. The debate and any decisions are still to come; neither the grouping nor the listing establishes agreement.

Single-sex NHS amendment watch: Continue to monitor Amendments 166, 260, 261 and 264, concerning sex recording, facilities, intimate-care requests and accommodation. The tracker records them as proposals, not enacted requirements. Monitor any changes to numbering, wording, grouping and eventual disposition in the current amendment register.

Children’s services and PATHWAYS: The later amendment material includes proposals concerning standards and safeguards for children’s gender-related healthcare, including amendments identified in the parliamentary research watch as 94A, 279QN, 279QP and 279QQ. Their current exact wording, sponsors and status should be checked against the latest marshalled list before any detailed legal claim is made. None is described here as agreed. The 22 October Deech debate remains a separate proceeding, not a Health Bill stage.

PATHWAYS written-question follow-up: Baroness Deech’s question HL4607 and the Government’s response should be reconciled against the published answer before drawing conclusions about the research team’s setup, recruitment, completion dates or adult follow-up. No trial recruitment or policy change is inferred from the Bill’s Committee proceedings.

Government policy and Healthwatch: The 28 October ministerial announcement not to proceed with the proposed abolition of Healthwatch is retained below as a reported Government policy reversal. The Bill’s published description and operative text must be checked for consequential amendments; an announcement alone does not remove provisions from legislation.

Primary sources: Parliament — Committee progress and 17 November preview (13 November) | 11 November official minutes | 12 November business motion | 17 November Order Paper | Current amendments | Bill publications and Hansard.

Earlier developments — historical entries retained

29 October check — official Hansard now available

28 October Committee: confirmed decisions and Healthwatch policy reversal

Government change of policy: During the first Committee sitting, Earl Howe welcomed a ministerial letter announcing that the Government would not proceed with the proposed abolition of Healthwatch. Baroness Merron acknowledged the announcement. This is a Government policy commitment reported in Parliament, not yet an enacted amendment to the Bill. Monitor the consequential amendment text and its progress.

Amendments agreed: Government amendments 1, 2 and 3 were agreed, providing for devolved-government consent in specified NHS England transfer schemes; Clause 2 was agreed as amended. Amendments 4 and 5, concerning a transition plan and NHS Supply Chain, were withdrawn after debate. In the earlier part of the sitting, Amendment 6 on health inequalities was withdrawn and amendments 7–11 were not moved. These are Committee-stage decisions, not Royal Assent.

What this means for Protect and Teach: The proceedings reviewed from the first Committee sitting on 28 October did not establish any new legal protections concerning single-sex NHS facilities or children’s participation in the PATHWAYS trial. The proposed amendments on single-sex NHS provision and accurate recording of sex remain under scrutiny in this tracker. We will report their outcomes when Parliament formally considers them. Verification note: This assessment relates to the proceedings reviewed; the complete sitting record and latest amendment register should be checked before drawing conclusions about every item considered that day.

Official Hansard — Health Bill, Committee day one (28 October) | Official Committee amendment register

28 October 2026 — Committee stage begins

First Lords Committee sitting; single-sex amendment groups expected later

The Health Bill began House of Lords Committee stage on 28 October. At that time, a parliamentary stakeholder update received by Protect and Teach reports that the first sitting is expected to consider only the earlier amendment groups, and that the single-sex NHS amendments are not expected to be reached on day one. This is an indication of expected debate order, not a record of proceedings completed.

Separate debate group: According to the update, amendments 260 and 261 (Baroness Cash) and 264 (Baroness Coffey) have been grouped together for debate on single-sex NHS provision, separately from puberty-blocker proposals. This group is expected late in Committee. Amendment 166 (Baroness Cash), concerning recording biological sex in patient records, is in an earlier patient-record group. Grouping and timing should be checked against the latest official grouping list.

Other proposals: The update places Lord Blencathra’s 240 (with Lord Patel, professional deregistration following sexual misconduct) and 279C in earlier groups, potentially for the second sitting. The wording and scope of 279C have not been established by this update and are not characterised here.

Not tabled or held over: The stakeholder briefing says Protect and Teach’s proposals labelled NC6 and NC8 were not tabled; details sought under NC1 and NC4, including under-18 accommodation and trust-by-trust breach figures, are not expressly included in the tabled amendments; and NC5 is being held for Report stage. These NC labels refer to stakeholder proposals and must not be mistaken for amendments agreed by Parliament.

Outstanding scrutiny: Monitor the precise text, debate, ministerial response and disposition of each amendment. A tabled amendment is not a legal requirement unless subsequently agreed and enacted.

Official Lords Committee amendment register | Bill stages and sitting dates

27 October 2026 — Tabled, not agreed

Single-sex NHS amendments now tabled for Lords Committee

The latest Committee amendment material identifies proposals concerning single-sex NHS facilities, same-sex intimate care, hospital accommodation and accurate recording of sex. These are proposed changes, not provisions enacted or agreed by Parliament.

Amendment 260 — Baroness Cash: single-sex changing, washing and toilet facilities for NHS staff, and single-sex wards and facilities for patients, with specified clinical exceptions. Its explanatory statement says it restates Commons NC143, rejected on 8 September.

Amendment 261 — Baroness Cash: patient requests for a same-sex practitioner and chaperone during intimate examinations or care, to be met where reasonably practicable, with reasons recorded if not met.

Amendment 264 — Baroness Coffey: hospital wards and sleeping accommodation organised by biological sex, defined in the proposed text as sex recorded at birth.

Amendment 166 — Baroness Cash: recording sex at birth in health information standards and the single patient record, with gender identity recorded separately where requested, and a review of NHS sex-data accuracy.

Amendment 240 — Lord Blencathra, with Lord Patel: professional deregistration following a finding of sexual misconduct. This concerns regulatory sanctions and is distinct from the single-sex facilities proposals.

Timing: Amendments 240, 260, 261 and 264 are placed after Clause 84; amendment 166 is placed after Clause 56. They are not expected to be reached at the first Committee sitting on 28 October. Further sittings are scheduled in November, subject to change.

Official Lords Committee amendment register — check latest wording and status

24 October 2026 — Watch Baroness Deech’s intervention: Watch Jennifer Thetford-Kay’s video extract of Baroness Deech speaking on children’s consent, puberty blockers and PATHWAYS (X). This is an extract from the 22 October Question for Short Debate, not a Health Bill proceeding. Read the full debate and ministerial response in Hansard.

Other 24 October tracker additions: The reported increase in the Lords amendment-register count is flagged for verification; Sex Matters’ BMA commentary is recorded as an attributed stakeholder issue pending direct-source checks.

22 October 2026 — Baroness Deech’s debate completed. Peers debated age, consent and assent in relation to puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and PATHWAYS. Baroness Cass contributed; Baroness Merron responded for the Government. This was a separate Question for Short Debate, not a Health Bill stage.

PATHWAYS and commissioning: The debate addressed trial eligibility and safeguards. The Government did not announce that the trial had been suspended or that its separate policy consideration concerning cross-sex hormones had concluded.

23 October — amendment register checked: The official Lords Committee register lists 203 proposed amendments. No matching formally published amendment reinstating Commons NC143 or corresponding to the single-sex NHS provision proposals reviewed has been identified. This does not rule out later tabling or publication. An amendment attributed to Lord Blencathra concerning professional deregistration following sexual misconduct is a separate subject.

23 October — Parliament confirms Committee timetable: Parliament published its Committee-stage announcement, confirming the 28 October start and seven currently scheduled sitting dates. This announcement is procedural, not a decision on any amendment.

28 October — Lords Committee scheduled: Amendment proposals are published but are not agreed changes. The rejected Commons NC142 and NC143 are not part of the Bill.

Official Hansard — 22 October debate | Lords Committee amendments | Parliament — 23 October Committee announcement

Current position (20 November): Five Lords Committee sittings have taken place, most recently 17 November. The next is scheduled for 23 November. See the new summary at the top for verified proceedings and decisions.

Current status: Lords Committee stage underway — commenced 28 October

The Health Bill completed its Commons stages on 8 September 2026 and received its First Reading in the House of Lords on 9 September 2026. It is before the Lords as HL Bill 52 (as brought from the Commons).

13 October 2026: The House of Lords completed Second Reading without a division. The Bill was committed to a Committee of the Whole House. Lord Rooker withdrew his proposed procedural amendment to the committal motion. Lord Blencathra raised single-sex NHS provision, staff protections and CQC accountability. These speeches and procedural decisions do not amend the Bill.

22 OCTOBER — AGE OF CONSENT DEBATE: COMPLETED

What was asked: Baroness Deech questioned whether children as young as 11 and 12 can meaningfully assent to the PATHWAYS puberty-blocker trial, and asked how their understanding, parental consent and potential longer-term risks would be assessed.

What was said: Baroness Cass explained that, for this approved research trial, children assent while parents consent; she said fewer than 20 of approximately 1,600 young people were at an early stage of consideration for enrolment. Baroness Merron defended the trial’s regulatory approval and safeguards, confirmed the minimum ages of 11 for girls and 12 for boys, and reiterated that routine puberty-blocker commissioning has ended. She said the outcome of the consultation on routine commissioning of masculinising and feminising hormones remained under consideration.

How it was left: The Minister answered the Question for Short Debate; there was no vote, change to the law or new statutory minimum age. The Government did not announce a change to PATHWAYS eligibility. The wider ethical and safeguarding disagreement remains unresolved.

What happens next: Monitor confirmation of actual trial recruitment, any published protocol or safety updates, the cross-sex hormone commissioning decision and subsequent parliamentary questions. Separately, the Health Bill’s first Lords Committee sitting commenced on 28 October, with further sittings listed for 3, 9, 11, 17, 23 and 25 November (subject to change).

Read the 22 October debate in Hansard

Read the 13 October House of Lords debate (Hansard) | Official Bill stages

Earlier parliamentary update — 14 November 2026 (archive)

Second Reading completed — 13 October

Lord Blencathra challenges Government on single-sex NHS provision

During Second Reading, Lord Blencathra (Conservative) asked when definitive NHS guidance would be published following the Supreme Court’s For Women Scotland judgment and the updated statutory EHRC Code of Practice. He also asked whether guidance would address single-sex wards and facilities, requests for female clinicians or chaperones wherever reasonably practicable, and protection from disadvantage for patients and staff seeking or defending lawful single-sex provision.

He separately questioned the Care Quality Commission’s effectiveness and accountability, arguing that it had inadequately addressed serious systemic failures in NHS services. These are concerns expressed by Lord Blencathra, rather than findings established by this tracker.

Protect and Teach parliamentary engagement: Cathy Mudge sent Lord Blencathra a separate briefing on single-sex NHS provision on 10 October 2026. The briefing and speech concern closely related issues; the tracker does not claim that the briefing prompted or shaped his speech.

Confirmed procedural outcome

Second Reading was completed; Lord Rooker’s procedural amendment was withdrawn. Committee began on 28 October. The official Lords amendment register now lists proposed amendments, with early Committee decisions now recorded in the 28 October Hansard; the later single-sex proposals have not been recorded as agreed. Speech contributions do not themselves constitute amendments.

Official Hansard — Health Bill, 13 October 2026 (corrected daily Hansard record).

Lords amendments and research — historical developments to 14 November 2026

Tabled proposals — no decisions

Committee-stage amendment register now available

UK Parliament has published Lords Committee-stage amendment proposals. Relevant subjects include children’s health outcomes, patient-data safeguards, reporting of medical malpractice, and retention of NHS identifiers and records after adoption. These are proposals, not agreed changes to the Bill. No direct replacement for Commons NC142 or NC143 has been identified in the proposals reviewed.

Official amendment register | Committee sitting dates

Parliamentary briefing — 15 October

Hormone treatments and age consent: Government policy

The House of Lords Library has published a briefing ahead of Baroness Deech’s 22 October Question for Short Debate. It covers puberty blockers, PATHWAYS and the current commissioning position for cross-sex hormones in under-18s. NHS England’s consultation response and final revised cross-sex hormone policy had not been published at the time of the briefing. The publication is background research, not a new statutory decision.

Read the House of Lords Library briefing

Amendment watch — proposals only

Single patient record: confidentiality and access safeguards

The published Lords Committee amendment register includes proposals addressing the single patient record, including access logs, audit, opt-out arrangements and safeguards for sensitive information. A proposal attributed to Baroness Hollins concerning confidential psychological therapy records warrants particular scrutiny of consent and exceptions for immediate risk. No such amendment has been agreed; precise wording and sponsors should be checked against the latest marshalled list before attributing a legislative outcome.

Official Lords Committee amendment register

27 October — New Lords amendments: single-sex NHS provision and sex recording

Tabled proposals — no decisions

Amendment 260 (Baroness Cash): would provide single-sex staff and patient facilities, with exceptions in specified patient-care settings. Its explanatory statement says it restates rejected Commons NC143.

Amendment 261 (Baroness Cash): would provide a right to request a same-sex practitioner and chaperone for intimate care, subject to reasonable practicability, and require explanation, recording and anonymised reporting where requests cannot be met.

Amendment 264 (Baroness Coffey): would require hospital sleeping accommodation to be organised by biological sex, defined in the proposal as sex recorded at birth.

Amendment 166 (Baroness Cash): would make sex at birth a mandatory field in relevant health information standards and the single patient record, allow gender identity to be recorded separately and require a data-accuracy review.

Amendment 240 (Lord Blencathra, co-signed by Lord Patel): proposes deregistration for professional sexual misconduct; it is a distinct patient-safety and regulatory proposal.

Legislative status: These are amendments proposed for Committee consideration. None is recorded here as agreed. Amendment 166 is placed after Clause 56; the others listed here are placed after Clause 84. No replacement for Commons NC142 has been identified in the material reviewed.

Official Committee amendments and current status | Committee stage and sitting dates

28 October — Committee begins: amendment groupings and outstanding proposals

Committee commenced — proposals not agreed

The first of seven currently scheduled House of Lords Committee sittings began on 28 October. A stakeholder parliamentary update indicates that the single-sex NHS proposals are expected in a later debate group, separate from puberty-blocker amendments. The timetable is indicative and can change.

Single-sex group (reported): Amendments 260, 261 and 264. Patient-record group (reported): Amendment 166. Earlier groups (reported): Amendments 240 and 279C, potentially considered at the second sitting. No decision on any of these amendments is recorded in this update.

Which Protect and Teach proposals remain outstanding?

  • NC1 and NC4: Stakeholder update says certain requested details, including provision for under-18s’ accommodation and trust-by-trust reporting of breaches, are not included in the tabled text.
  • NC6 and NC8: Not tabled, according to the update.
  • NC5: Reportedly reserved for Lords Report stage; not yet tabled at Committee.

Baroness Cash reportedly considers that the tabled amendments address the principal concerns. That assessment does not establish that all requested protections or reporting duties have been included. Protect and Teach will continue to track the differences between the original proposals and the amendments before Parliament.

Source status: Internal parliamentary stakeholder briefing received 28 October 2026; check amendment texts and official grouping lists for procedural confirmation. Official amendments.

24 October — Lords amendment register watch

Proposals, not decisions

The published Lords Committee amendment register was reported as showing 227 entries, compared with the 203 recorded in the tracker on 23 October. This count has not been independently reconciled amendment by amendment. It must not be interpreted as 24 new substantive amendments or as parliamentary approval.

Next verification: compare the actual new wording and sponsors for any proposals relating to PATHWAYS, children’s consent, patient confidentiality or single-sex NHS facilities.

Official Lords Committee amendment register

At a glance

Issue Watch 1

Puberty blockers / PATHWAYS

Commons New Clause 142 concerned puberty blockers for under-18s experiencing gender dysphoria or gender incongruence and proposed parliamentary approval for clinical trials involving their use.

NC142 REJECTED
Ayes 108  |  Noes 357
Lords developments under scrutiny
Issue Watch 2

Single-sex NHS provision

Commons New Clause 143 concerned single-sex changing, washing and toilet facilities for NHS staff and single-sex wards, toilets and washing facilities for patients, subject to specified exceptions.

NC143 REJECTED
Ayes 106  |  Noes 302
Lords developments under scrutiny

Neither NC142 nor NC143 forms part of the Bill now before the House of Lords. If peers wish to revisit either issue legislatively, a member of the Lords would need to table a new amendment.

Position at 27 October 2026: Lords amendments 260 (single-sex NHS facilities), 261 (same-sex practitioners and chaperones), and 264 (hospital accommodation by biological sex) have now been tabled. Amendment 166 concerns recording sex in health information; amendment 240 concerns professional deregistration for sexual misconduct. None has been agreed. No amendment reinstating Commons NC142 has been identified in the material reviewed.

Historical record below: The 23 October assessment predates the newly tabled amendments and is retained for transparency.

Position at 23 October 2026: Lords Committee amendments are now published. The proposals reviewed do not reinstate Commons NC142 or NC143; this is not a claim about amendments that may be tabled later.

Parliamentary research submissions — 10 October 2026

Parliamentary research submitted

Two distinct briefings, sent to different peers

Protect and Teach CIC has submitted two separate parliamentary briefings ahead of further House of Lords scrutiny: one on children’s informed consent, puberty blockers and PATHWAYS, prepared by Jennifer Thetford-Kay and sent to Baroness Deech; and one on single-sex NHS provision for patients and staff, prepared by Cathy Mudge and sent to the Rt Hon Lord Blencathra PC.

These are distinct submissions addressing different issues. Baroness Deech’s Question for Short Debate on 22 October 2026 is a separate parliamentary proceeding, not a stage of the Health Bill. Submission does not imply endorsement by a recipient or the tabling of an amendment.

Parliamentary progress

Commons First Reading
14 May 2026 — Complete
Commons Second Reading
1 June 2026 — Complete
Commons Committee
Complete
Commons Report Stage & Third Reading
8 September 2026 — Complete
Lords First Reading
9 September 2026 — Complete
Lords Second Reading
13 October 2026 — Complete; no division
Lords Committee
Commenced 28 October 2026; sittings held 3, 9, 11 and 17 November; next scheduled 23 November
Lords Report Stage
Awaited
Lords Third Reading
Awaited
Consideration of Lords amendments
Awaited
Royal Assent
Awaited

Issue Watch 1 — Puberty blockers and PATHWAYS

Commons position

New Clause 142

NC142 would have required the Secretary of State, within three months of Royal Assent, to make regulations preventing puberty blockers from being prescribed, dispensed or supplied to under-18s for treatment related to gender dysphoria or gender incongruence.

It would also have prevented those drugs being used in clinical trials for those purposes unless the particular trial had been approved by resolutions of both Houses of Parliament.

8 SEPTEMBER 2026
Ayes 108  |  Noes 357
NC142 rejected
Lords: watching

What happens now?

NC142 itself fell in the Commons. Protect and Teach will monitor the Lords stages for any new amendment concerning puberty suppression, PATHWAYS or parliamentary oversight of clinical trials involving children.

23 October review: Second Reading is complete. The Lords Committee amendment register contains tabled proposals, but no decision on them. No direct replacement for NC142 has been identified in the proposals reviewed.

Submitted — 10 October 2026

Children’s consent and PATHWAYS — briefing to Baroness Deech

Jennifer Thetford-Kay prepared a parliamentary research briefing on behalf of Protect and Teach CIC and submitted it to Baroness Deech ahead of her House of Lords Question for Short Debate on 22 October 2026.

The submission covers:

  • Whether children can provide sufficiently informed consent to puberty suppression and masculinising or feminising hormones;
  • The distinct requirements for ordinary medical treatment and participation in a clinical trial of an investigational medicinal product (CTIMP);
  • PATHWAYS eligibility ages of 11 and 12, and parental or representative consent and child assent;
  • The published evidence, longer-term uncertainty and safeguarding questions;
  • The regulatory chronology, research documentation and questions requiring a Government answer.

The material was supplied as a main parliamentary briefing, four supporting annexes, a four-page visual summary and a peers directory requested for parliamentary consideration.

Protect and Teach CIC’s position

Children cannot provide sufficiently informed consent to these interventions. This is the organisation’s safeguarding and policy assessment, distinguished in the briefing from the applicable legal tests, published research and regulatory decisions.

Parliamentary context: Baroness Deech’s debate is separate from the Health Bill’s legislative stages. The briefing’s submission does not establish that PATHWAYS recruitment has begun or that any peer has endorsed Protect and Teach CIC’s position.

PATHWAYS status: Starting

PATHWAYS trial watch

King’s College London’s public PATHWAYS page currently describes the project as “Starting”.

The modified trial protocol has received the necessary regulatory and research-ethics approvals. Protect and Teach has not recorded recruitment as having commenced unless and until that is publicly confirmed.

High Court judgment — 31 July 2026

Bayswater Support Group & Ors v Health Research Authority & Anor

In R (Bayswater Support Group & Ors) v Health Research Authority & Anor [2026] EWHC 2043 (Admin), Mr Justice Chamberlain refused permission to apply for judicial review and refused interim relief. The claimants were Bayswater Support Group, Keira Bell and James Esses.

The challenge concerned decisions of the Health Research Authority and Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency relating to PATHWAYS. The Court concluded that none of the five grounds advanced was arguable with a realistic prospect of success.

The judgment concerned the lawfulness of the regulators’ decisions and the public-law grounds on which they were challenged. It did not amount to the Court substituting its own clinical or ethical assessment of the trial for that of the specialist regulators. Read the press summary or full judgment .

Protect and Teach position

Protect and Teach opposes the PATHWAYS puberty-suppression trial on ethical and safeguarding grounds.

Our concern is whether exposing children to the known physiological effects, identified safety concerns and unresolved uncertainties of puberty suppression for the purpose of obtaining further evidence is compatible with safeguarding them from avoidable harm.

Our position is that it is not.

THE CENTRAL SAFEGUARDING QUESTION:

If significant uncertainty about an intervention is the reason further evidence is required, who carries the risk while that evidence is generated?

In PATHWAYS, it is the participating child.

We are tracking

  • PATHWAYS recruitment status
  • Regulatory, research-ethics and relevant legal developments
  • Safety information and protocol changes
  • Parliamentary questions and ministerial statements
  • Baroness Deech’s completed 22 October debate and any subsequent Government response or written follow-up
  • Any new Lords amendments

Separate parliamentary watch — Baroness Deech, 22 October 2026

Debate completed — 22 October

Puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones: age, consent and PATHWAYS

Baroness Deech led a House of Lords Question for Short Debate on hormone treatments and the age at which children can consent. Peers examined PATHWAYS, the distinction between a child’s assent and parental consent, clinical uncertainty and the evidential basis for treatment.

Baroness Cass discussed the legal and research context of consent and assent. She reported that fewer than 20 of approximately 1,600 patients seen by the new services were at an early stage of consideration for trial enrolment. That statement must not be interpreted as confirmation that trial recruitment or treatment had commenced.

Government response: Baroness Merron reaffirmed the Government’s support for the approved PATHWAYS research framework and its age and consent arrangements. She indicated that the outcome of NHS England’s separate consultation on routine commissioning of masculinising and feminising hormones for under-18s remained under consideration.

Protect and Teach parliamentary engagement: Jennifer Thetford-Kay submitted a research briefing to Baroness Deech on 10 October. Submission does not establish that it was cited, relied upon or endorsed during the debate.

Procedural distinction

The 22 October proceeding was not a Health Bill stage. It did not amend the Bill or announce suspension of PATHWAYS.

Video extract: Watch Jennifer Thetford-Kay’s clip of Baroness Deech’s 22 October contribution. This is an extract, not the full parliamentary proceeding; consult Hansard for the full debate and ministerial response.

Read official Hansard — 22 October 2026

Related stakeholder commentary — NHS sex-specific care

Stakeholder claim — original sources pending

Sex Matters has criticised the use of “gender history” language in professional healthcare discussion and argued for clear recognition of patients’ sex, particularly in intimate care. This is the organisation’s position, not a change to NHS policy or a finding that sex is known in every clinical situation. The underlying BMA wording and Sex Matters publication require direct-source verification before further detail or a publication date is attributed.

This issue is relevant to implementation of NHS England’s 15 October guidance on privacy, dignity and single-sex provision.

Issue Watch 2 — Single-sex NHS provision

Commons position

New Clause 143

NC143 would have required the Secretary of State to ensure the availability of single-sex:

  • Changing rooms for NHS staff;
  • Toilets and washing facilities for NHS staff;
  • Wards for NHS patients; and
  • Toilets and washing facilities for NHS patients.

The proposed clause also allowed specified exceptions concerning patient wards and facilities where necessary for children, intensive care, critical care and specialist high-observation areas including A&E resuscitation and initial theatre recovery.

8 SEPTEMBER 2026
Ayes 106  |  Noes 302
NC143 rejected
Lords: watching

Protect and Teach will monitor the Lords stages for any new amendment concerning single-sex NHS accommodation or facilities for patients or staff.

27 October update: Amendments 260, 261 and 264 now propose single-sex NHS provision and same-sex intimate-care arrangements. They are tabled proposals only; no Committee decision has been made. See the official amendments.

23 October review: Lord Blencathra raised the subject at Second Reading. NHS England published new guidance on 15 October. No direct replacement for NC143 has been identified in the proposals reviewed.

Submitted — 10 October 2026

Single-sex NHS provision — separate parliamentary briefing

Cathy Mudge prepared a separate briefing on behalf of Protect and Teach CIC concerning single-sex NHS provision for patients and staff, and sent it to the Rt Hon Lord Blencathra PC as a distinct submission from the briefing sent to Baroness Deech.

The subject of this submission is the provision of appropriate single-sex NHS accommodation and facilities, including questions of privacy, dignity, safety and safeguarding for patients and staff. These matters are tracked here in connection with the issues raised by Commons New Clause 143, which was rejected and is not part of the Bill currently before the Lords.

Status: Briefing sent to Lord Blencathra. Submission does not imply acceptance of its recommendations or that an amendment has been tabled.

House of Lords speech — 13 October 2026

Lord Blencathra — three questions on single-sex NHS provision

Speaking during Second Reading at approximately 6.12 pm, Lord Blencathra called for clear and consistent NHS implementation of lawful single-sex provision. He asked the Minister:

  1. When definitive NHS guidance would be published following the Supreme Court’s For Women Scotland judgment and the updated EHRC statutory Code of Practice;
  2. Whether guidance would address single-sex accommodation and requests for female clinicians or chaperones wherever reasonably practicable; and
  3. Whether women and NHS employees would be protected from disadvantage, disciplinary action or accusations of prejudice for seeking or defending lawful single-sex provision.

He also criticised the Care Quality Commission, questioning its effectiveness in responding to serious NHS failures and calling for stronger accountability.

Protect and Teach parliamentary engagement: Cathy Mudge submitted a briefing on single-sex NHS provision to Lord Blencathra on 10 October 2026. Proposed amendments are under consideration; none is presented here as tabled or agreed in the absence of an official parliamentary record.

Next check: Baroness Merron’s response to these questions and any subsequent tabled amendments. Lord Blencathra’s contribution does not itself establish a Government commitment or legislative change.

Read Lord Blencathra’s contribution in official Hansard (13 October 2026; uncorrected rolling record at this check).

NHS England guidance: Published 15 October

NHS England publishes new patient and staff guidance — 15 October

NHS England has published Privacy, dignity and safety in hospital accommodation and separate Guidance on NHS staff facilities. These address single-sex provision and the relationship between clinical need, privacy, dignity and safety. They are NHS guidance, not amendments to the Health Bill.

Outstanding implementation questions: children and young people’s wards; mental health accommodation; the scope of clinical exceptions; requests for same-sex intimate care or chaperones; staff facilities; breach reporting; and how trusts protect employees who raise lawful concerns.

Legal accuracy: The staff guidance reportedly refers to the EHRC’s revised Services Code as a draft, despite the Code having come into force on 5 August 2026. The precise page wording should be checked against the NHS PDF. Questions also arise about applying the Equality Act’s protection of philosophical belief and the proportionality principles in Higgs v Farmor’s School. These questions are not findings of unlawful conduct.

18 October reporting: The Guardian reports on an internal NHS England impact assessment identifying possible benefits and adverse impacts of the guidance. Until the original assessment is available, these are attributed prospective risks, not established outcomes.

NHS England — hospital accommodation guidance | NHS England — staff facilities guidance

Protect and Teach position

Clear single-sex provision is an important safeguard for privacy, dignity and safety, while appropriate additional arrangements can and should be made for individuals requiring them.

We are tracking

  • Implementation of new NHS England patient and staff guidance
  • Patient accommodation and facilities
  • NHS staff changing, washing and toilet facilities
  • Government statements
  • Lords debate
  • Any new Lords amendments

Lords scrutiny watch

Procedural amendment withdrawn

Lord Rooker — proposed amendment to the committal motion

Lord Rooker tabled an amendment to Baroness Merron’s proposed motion concerning the Bill’s committal to a Committee of the Whole House.

The proposed change would prevent Committee stage from commencing until a Minister had made a statement identifying which clauses and schedules of the Bill, including amendments made to it, the House of Commons did not have time to consider on the floor of the House.

This is an amendment to a parliamentary procedural motion, not an amendment to the text of the Health Bill.

Lord Rooker withdrew this proposed procedural amendment on 13 October. The original committal motion was agreed. This was not a change to the text of the Health Bill.

View the official Order Paper

Parliamentary accessibility development

Baroness Campbell — planned use of AI voice technology

The House of Lords announced on 9 October 2026 that Baroness Campbell of Surbiton is expected to use an AI voice generator to deliver her contribution during the Health Bill’s Second Reading.

Parliament describes this as the first use of AI voice technology by a Member or peer to deliver a speech in Parliament. The technology will enable her to communicate words she has written using a generated voice.

This is a parliamentary accessibility development. It does not establish Baroness Campbell’s position on the specific Health Bill issues tracked here.

Read the official House of Lords announcement

What we are watching next

Next parliamentary verification

28 October Committee — amendments and ministerial responses

Second Reading and committal are complete. Protect and Teach is monitoring:

  • Any Lords amendment concerning PATHWAYS, children’s consent or single-sex NHS provision;
  • Debate and decisions on relevant published Committee amendments;
  • Implementation of NHS England’s 15 October guidance and staff protections;
  • Further PATHWAYS trial and cross-sex hormone commissioning updates.

Hansard — Health Bill Second Reading | Official stages

Separate debate completed

22 October — Baroness Deech’s Question for Short Debate

Debate and Government response are now recorded above. Watch for any follow-up parliamentary questions or policy announcements. This was not a stage of the Health Bill.

Official Hansard

Read the evidence and take part

Protect and Teach has published a detailed analysis of the two issues and prepared a template letter for members of the public who wish to contact a member of the House of Lords.

About this tracker: Protect and Teach distinguishes between confirmed parliamentary or regulatory developments and our own safeguarding and policy analysis. Parliamentary proceedings, clinical-trial information and NHS guidance may change. We will update this page when substantive developments occur.

Information status: The 27 October amendment proposals remain tabled, not agreed; Committee commenced on 28 October. Earlier dated statements are retained as historical snapshots. The Health Bill completed Second Reading on 13 October and entered Lords Committee on 28 October. Baroness Deech’s 22 October debate has taken place and is a separate parliamentary proceeding. This page distinguishes submitted briefings from publicly confirmed speeches, commitments and tabled amendments.

Last substantive update: 20 November 2026. Parliamentary record checked: 20 November 2026.